general warning about forum behavior - particularly relating to threads about juniors

[boz-monaut]

threads have been removed and bans will be handed out if the ridiculous behaviour carries on

you've shown you can't play nicely - so this model of anonymous posters slagging everyone off simply isn't working

I'm open to suggestions on how to open the forum again for sensible discussion, so feel free to come up with ideas on how while we're all having a bit of time to cool off and calm down

I'm thinking that we require verification, to tie people to real names and clubs they are involved with - that way we won't have all this stupid carry-on

if this thread descends into farce, I will permanently ban those who resort to trolling and bickering

[Aegon]

threads have been removed and bans will be handed out if the ridiculous behaviour carries on

you've shown you can't play nicely - so this model of anonymous posters slagging everyone off simply isn't working

I'm open to suggestions on how to open the forum again for sensible discussion, so feel free to come up with ideas on how while we're all having a bit of time to cool off and calm down

I'm thinking that we require verification, to tie people to real names and clubs they are involved with - that way we won't have all this stupid carry-on

if this thread descends into farce, I will permanently ban those who resort to trolling and bickering

Kudos.

I'm happy with a verification model. We've met in person previously and will again this season whenever we play our O/35 catch up game.
If people have to put a real name, club, etc behind their posts I will assume that it wont descend into the farce that has occurred recently.

[ForeverRed]

👏👏👏👏👏👏

[Thomas477]

How about just not having any threads relating to junior comps? It’s a bit weird to discuss junior teams on a forum anyway in my opinion.

[Jardelsimage]

How about just not having any threads relating to junior comps? It’s a bit weird to discuss junior teams on a forum anyway in my opinion.

:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

[Bremsstrahlung]

Like the idea of real names requiring verification, to register to post in the local forums.
I think anonymity is an important component of the forum, allowing freedom to express ideas and issues, sometimes for the better.
However, it’s when that anonymity descends into bickering, name calling, relentless bullying, naming clubs in a derogatory manner, players, that’s when the problems start.

As a general rule, I think if you wouldn’t post something under your real name, don’t bother posting it at all when it comes to negative comments.


On the youth discussion, it’s no coincidence it was last years Youth and this years JDL thread that descended into idiocy, with parents exemplifying everything that’s wrong with junior football. For the most part, there’s some good discussion about what clubs and the competition/development program are doing well, areas that could use some attention and proposed changes are often discussed sensibly.
I don’t mind the generalised discussion about what the program is doing well, or not doing well, but maybe Thomas is right when it comes to more personal comments naming clubs, teams, individuals as when it gets to that level, it rarely ends well.


The local forum, and the forum itself, is a great place to discuss football with like minded, equally passionate people. It’s be a big shame if the minority ruined it for everyone.

[sapdad]

No need for verification.Just IP ban on the first stupid post,becuase its the same trolls starting it everytime and it just escalates.Problem is from what we've seen these people have no shame in real life either so they would probably be fine with everyone knowing their names it wouldnt change their behaviour.It always stems from the same place,an outdated and childish rivalry between two clubs who no one really gives a shit about.The clubs involved would be embarrassed at their names being involved in this type of garbage.The youth and JDL threads were really important information for me over the last few years with one child making the transition from JDL to NPL and our family still being involved in the JDL program.Things we learned on here proved really valuable in my kid finding a great environment and I would hate for other parents to miss out on the same info or the same resources that would make their childs experience the best it could be.
tl;dr perma ban the clowns.

[boz-monaut]

banning an IP has issues as it's very easy to get around

I'm happy to just have a break from junior threads for a while until the angry dads out there cool down and maybe reconsider their approach to their kids game

I'm open for anyone sensible to assist with moderation as well

[Aegon]

banning an IP has issues as it's very easy to get around

I'm happy to just have a break from junior threads for a while until the angry dads out there cool down and maybe reconsider their approach to their kids game

I'm open for anyone sensible to assist with moderation as well

I'd be happy to help, hopefully I am sensible enough :) Feel free to PM me if you want to take me up on the offer.

[plague]

I'm open for anyone sensible to assist with moderation as well

Reporting for duty Mr Boz.
These clowns wont even see me coming.

[boz-monaut]

you'll note I used the word "sensible"

[TRUMP TOWER]

Keep the JDL forums closed. Why do we need a JDL forum? No scores, no tables and it’s meant for fun and development is it not. All you see is the competitive parents on there that need to get a life. Don’t give them a platform to carry on. All they do is single out individuals and clubs behind fake names. Anything they need they can get from nnsw websites or their clubs. There is a JDL page on Facebook I’m pretty sure and no one carry’s on there do they? No they don’t because they have to use their real names and are too scared to say anything negative. Keep it closed, best decision you have made.

[jessepinkman]

I think we can all agree that JDL is full of coaches who think they're the next Ange and parents who think their kid is the next Cahill, all forgetting they're playing under 12s football in Newcastle.

JDL is full of cringey adults in real life and unfortunately, behind the veil of anonymity, it's even worse online.

We don't need a platform for parents who think their kid is the next breakthrough star - mainly because if their kid is a future pro, they aren't likely to need to take to an anonymous forum to chest beat to try to convince themselves of that.

18s and up (senior football) is all that needs to be discussed. Club actions as a whole should be fine too (eg xyz club should really field all youth teams, XYZ club has a great jdl program I'd recommend) but year on year the JDL forum is just full of parents living through their (primary school aged) children and it's just gross to read. Embarassing even.

[KITZ]

Keep the JDL forums closed. Why do we need a JDL forum? No scores, no tables and itÂ?s meant for fun and development is it not. All you see is the competitive parents on there that need to get a life. DonÂ?t give them a platform to carry on. All they do is single out individuals and clubs behind fake names. Anything they need they can get from nnsw websites or their clubs. There is a JDL page on Facebook IÂ?m pretty sure and no one carryÂ?s on there do they? No they donÂ?t because they have to use their real names and are too scared to say anything negative. Keep it closed, best decision you have made.

you are acting like you werent involved, you were a significant part of the problem. Thanks for making things worse, at least take ownership and donT pretend you weren?t a part of it.

I believe several people only joined recently to cause issues, maybe limiting new member posts would be an option in the future. It might stop the one off posts across the forums or the people who are only joining to cause issues like what has happened in recent weeks. People are also cross posting issues from one forum to another, that is another problem as it starts to drag arguments into topics where it?s not relevant.

It does concern me that several of the posters may be in positions of responsibility and donT understand their duty of care, both legally and under their WWCC for the minors they are responsible for. I really hope its something they reflect on as I did when I realised I should have worded my response in a way that showed concern because it obviously didnt come across that way, but it?s hard to respond to people who are supposed to be adults in a calm reflected manner, when they just don?t get it.

I for one apologise for my part in helping that devolve. But I hope that situations like that can be helped to be prevented rather than managed after they have happened.

Good luck with whatever you decide to do.

[Aegon]

My personal take on it.

Just like the Youth thread there are good conversations to be had, experiences to be shared, etc. Especially around the end of each season with regards to trials, EOI's etc.

Unfortunately too often it devolves into name calling or personal attacks.

Happy enough for it to continue (with some extra moderation) under the caveat that anyone stepping over the line will be warned & naming individuals is not to be tolerated.

[BS detecor]

Maybe keep the JDL forum but add an ?obsessed with Stoj? forum as well. I just went through last years SAP page and it?s all the exact same people saying the exact same things about the exact same person. Just a thought

[The Magician]

Maybe keep the JDL forum but add an “obsessed with Stoj” forum as well. I just went through last years SAP page and it’s all the exact same people saying the exact same things about the exact same person. Just a thought

Next year he will be coaching 13s NPL so JDL page will get a rest

[Bremsstrahlung]

I?m slightly amused that we?ve already named somebody in the thread about not naming people.

[boz-monaut]

this carry on isn't exactly going as it needs to reopen threads and avoid bans

[terry]

I?m slightly amused that we?ve already named somebody in the thread about not naming people.
Crazy but its hard to hide facts but that's for another forum.


Reporting for duty Mr Boz.
These clowns wont even see me coming.

Who's this johnny come lately?

[Bremsstrahlung]

:deadhorse:

[Unhappygreek]

:deadhorse:

I?ve watched a few of that JDL magic coaches games against my sons sides over the years and his not afraid to make changes to change game.
I?ve also seen that his got a few kids into tsp and the jets so his obviously doing something right.
I think some of these doubters should take note and learn instead of bagging coaches who have a bit of character and bring excitement to JDL.
I think people have a lot to learn from watching his style !
Great coach !

[Thomas477]

I?ve watched a few of that JDL magic coaches games against my sons sides over the years and his not afraid to make changes to chase a game to get a result.
I?ve also seen that his got a few kids into tsp and the jets so his obviously doing something right.
I think some of these doubters should take note and learn instead of bagging coaches who have a bit of character and bring excitement to JDL.

Good god, this isn?t a thread to discuss the JDL or TSP.

[jessepinkman]

I?ve watched a few of that JDL magic coaches games against my sons sides over the years and his not afraid to make changes to change game.
I?ve also seen that his got a few kids into tsp and the jets so his obviously doing something right.
I think some of these doubters should take note and learn instead of bagging coaches who have a bit of character and bring excitement to JDL.
I think people have a lot to learn from watching his style !
Great coach !

This isn’t a JDL thread.

[terry]

I?ve watched a few of that JDL magic coaches games against my sons sides over the years and his not afraid to make changes to change game.
I?ve also seen that his got a few kids into tsp and the jets so his obviously doing something right.
I think some of these doubters should take note and learn instead of bagging coaches who have a bit of character and bring excitement to JDL.
I think people have a lot to learn from watching his style !
Great coach !

shutup fool. Take your lies somewhere else

[MFKS]

FFS I ain't even involved and you ****s can't keep on the straight and narrow

Sort your shit out

[KITZ]

FFS I ain't even involved and you ****s can't keep on the straight and narrow

Sort your shit out

Makes me wonder if they can even comprehend how a game of football is played, when they can't understand the much simpler rules of a forum.

[northern_swan]

This thread, and the associated thread deletion is nothing more than a sideshow from the real issue, which is the behaviour that is condoned, and indeed promoted from a certain club.

[Aegon]

Thread closed.
A few posts have been removed in order to keep the focus on the original message.