Pretty Obvious isn't it. Because it has cost them 3 pointsQuote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
Printable View
Pretty Obvious isn't it. Because it has cost them 3 pointsQuote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
Suppose if that's the team/club mentalityQuote:
Originally Posted by winner
Would those same team mates be filthy on a keeper for letting a goal in or a striker for missing a goal ???
But doesn't sound like a team to me
Im fine with them losing the points, but not sure why Lambton should get given the three points, they lost the game, you are punishing Edgeworth, why reward Lambton ??Quote:
Originally Posted by winner
I would blame the registrar & related committee members. It's up to the admin of the club to let coaches know who they can & can't choose to play each week. Surely whoever takes charge of rego @ Edgy should have a list of people who are registered but not financial, who are fully registered, and who are not registered. All they needed to do was say "don't play that guy this week, he hasn't paid/registered yet".Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
It's the same as suspensions - coaches should pick their strongest team each week and it's up to the club admin to tell the coaches they can't pick a certain player due to suspension that week. Obviously this eg takes into account that NNSW would need to do their job in notifying the club of the suspension.
So with Pratty leaving Weston, we're is his likely destination? Which teams would be interested in taking him? Surely he will find another gig in the npl and not have to drop down to NewFm.
Adamstown, Valentine are probably two clubs that could do with him, but from all reports he can't train.Quote:
Originally Posted by onlooker
I wouldn't think Adamstown with Carter being there and captain.Quote:
Originally Posted by mervan
I was at Weston last weekend and did hear he has been showing up to training of late
There is a couple of cashed up NewFM clubs, 1 in particular has a Weston connection. Wherever he goes he is a walk up start, would be an improvement to any NewFM team and some NPL teams.
How can some players be punished with Bans etc and other not when they are unregistered?Quote:
Originally Posted by GO AWAY
Scott missed last week due to suspension and this week coming .Quote:
Originally Posted by onlooker
Who is in goals at magic this year??
Couldn't make training before Ben Kelly arrived but when there is competition for 1st spot he can make training. Deserves to be droppedQuote:
Originally Posted by onlooker
Don't think Carter is captain at the Buds this yearQuote:
Originally Posted by onlooker
Spoke to Carts yesterday. Available this weekend as only received a 1 match suspension for his tackle in the ffa cupQuote:
Originally Posted by Atown
He won't be playing this weekendQuote:
Originally Posted by winner
Think carter does pretty well tbh. Definitely one of the better keepers.
Adamstown truly missed him on the weekend. That game probably could've gone either way if he was there.
You sir are a strange manQuote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
agree forever,Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
This bloke has not got a clue...
If i was playing and a player did not register i would be filthy..
The way the registration process works is a two fold system.Quote:
Originally Posted by cobra23
The player themselves registers on my football club, but then the club administration have to approve and ensure the appropriate paperwork is filed with Northern. (Doesn't mean you wouldn't be annoyed though, but the fault may not be with the player themselves).
Happy to be different in my thoughts to youQuote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
But while you are still assuming every one knows everything
Did everyone know that a player aged under 18 years of age cannot register online via FFA web site for a senior NPL team
The only option that comes up is for NPL youth 17's
It is as issue with the site
If I were Edgeworth or any other club facing same I would be protesting
How can you penilise someone for not doing something you did not facilitate ????
I'm sorry, how did every other player in the competition register?Quote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
It's a shame pratty couldn't get to his 200 games. Especially since he'd actually been training for the first time this decade by all reports.
Wouldn't mind seeing how many players left under piggo as apposed to Trev...
They may have left under piggo but he did make the gf, Trev has a lot of ground to make up
at a slightly different angle to the Pratt situation. Fairly often a couple of members on here say that players have no loyalty blah blah blah. They go around chasing the money etc. And to some degree i do agree.
I think it's fair to say that there is no loyalty in football period
Or maybe at Weston they don't like people that succeed? Piggo does well and he gets the punt. Pratt goalkeeper of the year and gets the punt. Perhaps, people at Weston are best off underperforming?
I'm sorry, I will type slower for youQuote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
The problem was if you turned 16 or 17 this year, and wanted to register for an NNSWF NPL club then the only option that came up was NPL youth 17's registering for senior NPL was not an option offered
This probably effected a few but certainly not every other player !!!!
The penalty would only stand in the nnswf kangaroo court, if you are going to make people do something a certain way than you have to ensure that the people can do it, can't then penalise people for them not being able to do something your software could not accommodate
There was a fix, but it took club involvement so took it out if player hands
So back to reds comment that every player knows, yes maybe but they can't do what the system won't allow
even if he registered in 17s he would be right . dumb by club, were there u/17s in 22s
The only person to go under piggo was himself.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
End of the day the club has to make sure their players are eligible to play even if the player should've known. Responsibility ends with the committee.Quote:
Originally Posted by idontwannaplaywithhowey
Having a dummy spit and leaving the club because you sat on the bench for one game is not getting the punt.Quote:
Originally Posted by immersion
piggo couldn't handle the banjo , so gooone
Exactly.Quote:
Originally Posted by Goatscheese
Much appreciated. However, they are the only club to lose points? So everybody else must have figured it out of rested their players.Quote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
Docking of points is justified if that is the case. What are they going to protest? If they are the only ones who can't register a player before playing them, they have no excuses.
At the end of the day the club has a print off or access to a list of registered players.
CorrectQuote:
Originally Posted by Goatscheese
I know forever red will have trouble accepting that a committee might have made a mistake
It's easy to call every one dumb and to assume every one knows as much as every one else but end of the day obviously not every one knew and ultimately it is the registrar who has to know who is good to play and who is not
That's why team mates can't be filthy at each other in this instance, filthy with club yes or committee yes
So your telling a bloke turns up to play knowing he hasn't registered himself online yet it's someone else's fault, don't think so
Pratty has signed with Magic, according to my sources
Anybody know tonight's scores?
Edgy 2-0... But NNSWF just found out the ref was not registered and awarded the points to the old man with 3 teeth missing sitting in the corner at Edgie Bowlo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Speedymetric
He has been training with the squad for months, he may have even payed rego to the club. It is still the committees fault for not ensuring every player in their squad is registered.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
Considering this is a semi-professional outfit and the squad is selected the committee should ensure that the squad that has been selected by their officials can play and if one isn't they are responsible for informing the coach and manager. Had the coach and manager ignored that then the blame rests with the coach and manager, but if no one informs them they aren't to know.
But as WB said you can't accept that committee members make mistakes, so no point hashing over it. Committee members are volunteers so sometimes they will make mistakes they just need to accept it, own up to their failings and learn from it to prevent it happening again.
We're is an abbreviation of we are. You should have used where.Quote:
Originally Posted by onlooker
How can you spell facilitate but not penalize, strange.Quote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue