until of course the same people moaning about not having a referral system then moan about how many wrong decisions don't get referred.
Printable View
until of course the same people moaning about not having a referral system then moan about how many wrong decisions don't get referred.
Although having said that I wish it was around in the Brisbane/Perth GF a few years back.
The experiment would have ended that day and stamped never to return.
Agree. League started tampering with the rules and they haven't recovered. The more complexity you bring in leaves more to interpretation and more chances for error to.occur.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilso8948
Football is fine the way it is.
All football needs is for referees bosses to tell their referees ok every game if you call something a foul early on then its a foul the rest of the game full stop. Sick of one team hacking players with nothing happeningQuote:
Originally Posted by Jeterpool
Agree with those who say human error has always been part of the game. No matter how they try and implement it, replays will halt the progress of matches, however slightly
Wait until you see the changes for next season!Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilso8948
Stop showing replays.
99% of the problem gone right there.
Seriously though, leave the game that way it is.
Just get better standard referee's and leave the game as is
There is one big positive for the Video Ref in the NRL.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeterpool
No matter how good or bad it works it gets people talking about the game.
The publicity the game gets out of every mistake is immense.
Just look at how decisions in football when not black or white but shades of grey get debate.
Look at the Berisha V Miller challenge in the GF a few years back. Many say pen many say dive
Video technology there is useless. It is an interpretation decision for the ref.
He either says contact sufficient for a penalty or contact occurred but insufficient for a penalty.
You will never get agreement on that one with a video ref
What kind of drugs are you on?Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
Berisha completely missed the ball and dived. Video ref there would've been spot on and ruled a dive, and a yellow card...
He was ankle tapped which made him miss the ball.Quote:
Originally Posted by tomo
That's the other side of the argument... and is the exact point the Member is making.
I bet you're one of those people who say Lucas Neill never touched Grosso.Quote:
Originally Posted by tomo
He ankle tapped himself!Quote:
Originally Posted by Grimario
Grim is right...I have the game. No matter how many times you watch it you can see a 50/50 decision that comes down to the refs interpretation.
Liam Miller made the slightest bit of contact.Quote:
Originally Posted by tomo
Berisha then made a meal of it.
Yeah he dived and played it for all it was worth.
Problem is here Miller should never ever have made any contact on the bloke. Everyone knows he will make a meal of anything. He gave Berisha the chance to make a meal of it. Just as Luca$h did on Grosso. Gave the bloke the chance he took it.
Hey I don't agree with the decision but I can see why the ref gave Berisha and Grosso as pens
Miller gave him a tap but the clincher was that there was a dik in goals called vuckavitch so Perth deserve to lose like that
https://www.theguardian.com/football...-replacing-ceo
Bakries have held onto the roar.
Is that like when Tinkler held onto the Jets?? We'll see six months from now... :deadhorse:Quote:
Originally Posted by belchardo
One more f**k up from Bakries after the Jets are sold and the roar will be in the FFA's handsQuote:
Originally Posted by turbojetfireV8
Bakries selling the club to a Melbourne consortium
Bakeries retaining a stake but not in control, apparentlyQuote:
Originally Posted by lil_masi
Luciano Trani announced as asistant
Assistant for whom?
NBN said assistant to MillerQuote:
Originally Posted by Couscous
We are luc trani's 5th club in the a-league.
Seems to be well respected by those in the know. Certainly doesnt have the intimidation factor that jp had though
So he has been at 4 clubs and neither of them have retained him and no one has given him the top job.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tommyjet
Yet you think he is a good pick up??
RanieriQuote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
I'm disappointed as my BIL thought it was Rado Vidosic we were picking up... I know Portaloo tweeted a congrats to Luc, but anyone know much about him, can't say he has as high a profile as JP?
We could sign pep guadiola and you'd find a problem with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
Read my post again and find where i said it was a good pick up. Football people who have had something to do with him have given him a glowing reference.
Also your point that he has had 4 other clubs reeks of football naivety.but then i should expect that.
None of his moves over the years have been linked to poor performances or any personal falling out. So, given the shit we have accepted over the years at the Jets I think Luciano Trani is one of our better acquisitions.Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
You said he is well respected by those in the know.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tommyjet
Yet 4 clubs think that highly of him they haven't retained him.
Obviously they not know what all these other people in football seem to know.
Do you honestly think a bloke who achieved nothing at 4 better clubs than us and wasn't wanted by them all of a sudden is a great pick up for us??
Typical HAL
Recycling of other people's garbage.
Is this bloke the best assistant Millertime can get.
I think not.
Once again FFA throwing us under the ****ing bus
Why appoint an assistant now. Why can't the new Chinese overlord appoint the replacement for JPD??
Also I hearing that the FFA are bending over backwards to get Cahill to Heart.
Even gonna change rules to allow.
News is slow in LoS
You ****s raging on about a lack of a ****ing marquee and being run on the smell of an oily rag.b y the useless ****s at the FFA yet they try and allow shit like this for the big teams or what??
Firstly, it's more likely that Miller actually chose Tranny and the FFA chose JP, than the opposite, The FFA are a lot less involved now than they were last year. So this could actually be a tactical move by Miller to get someone beside him that has the same thoughts. Thats a glass half full view of it, but we don't know who chose LT.Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
Also, New owners can sack both of them as soon as they come in so it's not really the end of the world in that respect. We weren't going to sign a world-class assistant coach anyway so that points pretty mute. This may be Miller getting it done quickly to save risking his decision being dismissed by new owners.
MootQuote:
Originally Posted by Frodo
:gent:
Shut up furns (ie be moot)Quote:
Originally Posted by furns
Where did I say we have to have a world class assistant??Quote:
Originally Posted by Frodo
I just said we should get the best we can get.
This bloke isn't even the best available judging by the 4 clubs who have failed to retain him.
It's a stop gap measure. Whilst we are in this ownership limbo with waiting for Mr Lee to arrive the FFA should have a tight hold on the reigns and not be making any decisions or sanctioning any.
Being the ownership is meant to be sorted in 2-3 weeks anyway I fail to understand why the FFA and Millertime can not wait to then
Maybe out of the people who applied, we got the best we could get.Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
Even with the rumoured new owner, there would be a lot of question marks about the club. One obvious one being, does the new owner have the intention of bringing in their own staff. This job could be a very short tenure. That in itself could have culled a lot of potential applicants straight up.
I don't know much about the guy, so I am not going to cast any judgement on his quality, but there are a few decisions lately that I think should have been left for the new owner.
- The coffs home game
- Staffing such as assistant coach
Respected by those in the know.
Disrespected by those who in all serious know **** all.
Welcome to Newy.
I think we are grown up enough to make up our own minds on each appointment. Respect has to be earned and this "in the know" shit is quite tiresome. If you know tell it or stfu. like the players lets see how he goes first before we get all joyous.
Wasn't Stubbins respected, and look how well that turned out.
I still need an answer on Steve Lustica ay.
I feel it hasn't been discussed enough.