Lots of complaints about the way the cup is run. Would love to hear opinions on how you'd run it if you were making the draw
Printable View
Lots of complaints about the way the cup is run. Would love to hear opinions on how you'd run it if you were making the draw
9 NPL Clubs and top 7 New FM =16 seaded to the round of 32Quote:
Originally Posted by monz6
Remaining New FM Clubs put in with the Zone league's in Qualifying rounds to get 8 Qualifers= 8 Qualifers
Northern Inland = 2 Qualifers
Far North Coast = 2 Qualifers
North Coast = 2 Qualifers
Mid North Coast = 2 Qualifers
Total= 16
Seaded= 16
Southern Pool= 8
Northern Pool= 8
That's your 32. The 16 seaded drawn against 16 Qualifers, Qualifers are the home team.
Then from the round of 16 1st team drawn is the host, Finalist get the 2 FFA Cup spots.
Gotta get spellcheck on here, some of the spelling is atroshus!!
Missed an i the first time text predictor took over after that. After editing one mistake i couldn't be arse changing all of them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tonester
Not your fault some of the spelling is seady!!ha!Quote:
Originally Posted by Premy
Only if that club also constantly gets special treatment from Northern as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by MFKS
This draw sounds way too fair and the best teams would come through to the round of 16 teams.Quote:
Originally Posted by Premy
Perfect :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Premy
59 Teams
9 NPL
11 NewFM
10 ZPL
10 ZL1
10 ZL2
9 ZL3
First Round
39 ZL teams
1 bye, 19 winners
= 20 left
Second Round
Add 11 NewFM teams, 31 teams
1 bye, 15 winners
= 16 left
Third Round
Add 9 NPL teams, 25 teams
1 bye, 12 winners
= 13 left
Fourth Round
13 teams
1 bye, 6 winners
= 7 left
Fifth Round
7 teams
1 bye, 3 winners
= 4 left
Stop talking common sense, its not as fun!Quote:
Originally Posted by The Postman
Because I hate BYES and no Club should get a free pass through to the next round.Quote:
Originally Posted by Premy
Last 4 ZL3 Clubs playoff= 2 winners
Qualifying round 1
2 Playoff winners + 5 ZL3 + 9 ZL2 = (2+5+9=16) 8 Winners
Qualifying round 2
Round 1 (8) + 4 remaining New FM + 10 ZPL + 10 ZL1 =(8+4+10+10=32) 16 Winners
Qualifying round 3
Round 2 winners (16) = 8 Winners, progress to the round of 32 joining the 8 Northern Clubs and 16 seeded Clubs.
It doesn't matter what system everyone thinks is the answer the only one that counts is the official one so please stop boring the tripe out of me with this mindless, meaningless drivel.
Maybe this will help:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tonester
https://www.google.com.au/webhp?sour...ion%3A%20forum
Just saw on Facebook; Belswans 4-3 over Jesmond tonight. Rams lead at half-time but Belswans got the job done, a 19's and 17's player got on the scoresheet so maybe not a top-tier squad but good for the club nonetheless. Westy v Thornton tomorrow will be interesting.
Probably best to avoid the Internet altogetherQuote:
Originally Posted by Tonester
Probably best to discuss things that are relevant not some meandering claptrap eh!Quote:
Originally Posted by The Postman
Not one little bit. I am open to discussion all day long but this is just like having teeth pulled without drugs. Comments on what is happening is good, unless you can change the way the draw is done do we need to know every Tom, Dick & Harrys version of how the draw should be done, I don't think so it's boring.Quote:
Originally Posted by immersion
Good post, gives factual comment doesn't drift off into fantasy world, thanks.Quote:
Originally Posted by NewyTy
Before people start going off the idea (in my mind )of this forum is for stimulating conversation & with due respect discussion about what if the draw was this or that doesn't make the brain buzz with excitement, besides I hate getting up for work this early!
The fact that there are "byes" for teams to get into the quarter finals of a Nationwide Competition is an absolute joke.
You don't see Cambridge getting bye into the 4th round of FA Cup.
There has to be a better way.
Give 20 byes out in the first round if need be to the highest ranked teams and go from there.
We also need to figure out what we want our regions FFA Cup draw to achieve. Do we want a random draw where the cup concept of a team getting a good run is the foundation. Or do we want a draw that ensures our best teams progress to represent our region.
The elite teams will say the latter. The lesser teams will say they want to live the dream of a cup run.
Look at Balmain last year, 3/4th tier in sydney, progressed to play victory.
3rd or 4th tier probably equals northern NPL, that's the issue we face, south cardiff travelled to Melbourne and faced a 3rd tier Victorian side which would have quite easily competed in northern NPL, due to a larger population 3rd tier competitions in Sydney/Melbourne and Brisbane to lesser extent are of high quality where as our second tier teams struggle, I think we get a bit carried away with the quality in northern NPL, can't recall recently of a local player being plucked to sign an A league contract where as even Tasmania seem to provide a few each year
I was more so using it as an example that a random draw can mean teams of lower divisions can make it through. Whereas with the draw as it is at the moment, you'd never see Cardiff City or Other ZPL teams make the final 32.
But I do agree with your statements. We should be doing better as a region.
Can you count Hoole as a Local Player to get signed to A- league?
That's all well and good for the lower grade teams to be pumping their chests about making it to the later stages of the cup but in the current format they look a little silly doing so. My point is everybody states they love the romance of the cup but at the end of the day this romance is there because the lower sides get a an opportunity to defeat the higher sides and not handed a free pass. The draw for the English FA Cup is held correctly with the stronger lower grade clubs winning the right to play the higher division clubs later in the draw then all the club are placed into the 1 pot and drawn against each other.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
NNSWF had made the cup a farce by being politically correct and bending over backwards to give the lesser sides a free ride. Get it correct NNSWF or risk losing the bigger clubs and the support of the fans.
Whilst I'm one that plays for those lower clubs I wholeheartedly agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zico
The mock draw I done on the previous page supports this, the lower clubs that have a chance to be that David V Golioath story win the right to complete against your stronger clubs and by logic after winning that right they should at least be strong enough to not get completely embarrassed by the top end clubs.
Umm...Apparently Westy have called off their FFA cup game tonight due to the weather.....
Pardon my scepticism but unless Westy has their own weather system the few showers we had this morning would barely have softened the ground up.
Surely they could play just the one FFA cup game....or is there an ulterior motive - to stay fresh for Lakes on Saturday?
Or why didn't NNSWFF move it to LMRFF or see if there was someone who may be able to host it so it could be played tonight.Quote:
Originally Posted by LongSufferingFan
We haven't had a drop of rain for 5 weeks, surely we didn't get enough this morning to wash anything out!Quote:
Originally Posted by LongSufferingFan
This is where local football lets itself down, both club and nnswf are at fault here, plenty of grounds this could of been transferred to, where's the bloody drainageQuote:
Originally Posted by LongSufferingFan
Yep, looking out my front door now and it's sunny/overcast. Westy have let themselves down with this call. There'll be washouts every round if this is all it takes. There's a big difference between one cup game and a full matchday of four games back to back. Should have been played.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
And yet you post at 3am and then again 2 hours later about it with no one saying anything. Seems it does get you stimulated.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tonester
I hear Bero is keen to host a game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Local Rules
If it really was washed out then Weston are going to have a lot of rescheduled games this year.
It's taken you 17 hours to realize that.You must be a rocket scientist or someone who has plenty of time on their hands.Quote:
Originally Posted by Goatscheese
In my opinion, they are perhaps heading in the correct direction. Initially, the Solo Cup or whatever it was, cost a fair bit of $$$$ for clubs to enter, so, to increase the participation, they doctored the draw a little bit over the years to guarantee representation. As, hardly anybody from lower leagues would pay for a $$$ trial game. SO, they needed numbers.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zico
I'm not sure what bigger clubs would give up a crack at reaching the final 32...Really, the opportunity is there for the 9 NPL teams to push forward in this competition and make a bit of a name for themselves now.
As and aside, isn't the FFA Cup final 32 draw rigged so A-League teams play each other?
In my opinion, they are perhaps heading in the correct direction. Initially, the Solo Cup or whatever it was, cost a fair bit of $$$$ for clubs to enter, so, to increase the participation, they doctored the draw a little bit over the years to guarantee representation. As, hardly anybody from lower leagues would pay for a $$$ trial game. SO, they needed numbers.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zico
I'm not sure what bigger clubs would give up a crack at reaching the final 32...Really, the opportunity is there for the 9 NPL teams to push forward in this competition and make a bit of a name for themselves now.
As and aside, isn't the FFA Cup final 32 draw rigged so A-League teams play each other?
You are correct about the A League clubs having a different pot to the lower league clubs. I am not a fan of this either, it should be a single pot draw all the way (still keep the qualifying zones but once qualified all in 1 pot).Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
I understand what you are saying concerning the $$$$ to enter the comp but why do clubs have to pay this amount? Surely the expenses from NNSWF aren't that high to run the comp but if it is then get sponsors to cover a large part of the cost instead of putting it into their coffers.
Once again the issue from NNSWF revolves around how much profit they can make from the clubs rather than whats best for the clubs.
I'm purely speculating here, and would love some actual figures, but I don't think the cost is so much of an issue for lower league clubs now. I think NPL clubs pay a bit more, but I think the fee for non NPL teams is substantially lower. In the earlier years there used to be prizemoney in each round. So the more you progressed the more money, so lower clubs were struggling to justify paying $1000 to enter. Tournament they needed to win4 games in to get their money back kind of thing.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zico
Now, there's no such prizemoney as far as I'm aware. Only the final 32 of FFA Cup get remuneration. As far as I believe.
Just confirming, I'm just saying what was the case over the last few years, and I think we should start to see a shift as it is a FFA comp not a NNSW competition. So to speak. They administrate it locally, but don't have the responsibility they did previously.
There's only remuneration if you win your first game in the round of 32, pretty sure NAB sponsor the FFA cup nationally
NAB sponsor the WESTFIELD FFA Cup?Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
A-League $10,000, NPL $2500 below NPL (zone etc) $250... Only prize money of you won your Round of 32 Match $1500-2000... If you work on 600 participating teams you can calculate the prize pool by checking how many npl clubs there are around the coutnry, know how many A League teams then times the remainder by $250.00Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
NNSWF used to give teams that had to travel to Coffs for the NNSW final $500 travel compensation, state cup winner got $1500 extra and runner up another $500 i think...
FFA pay for travel and accommodation for 20ppl if you make the round of 32, considering this is a pretty big country its not a bad deal.
My point is why the large fee? NNSWF and the FFA should be encouraging the clubs to enter the comp and surely the $2500 and $10000 is over the top. This is money that could be spent on facilities, coaching development or the club could make it cheaper for the youth sides to play instead of hitting parents for $800 - $1250 a season.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Just find it poor form to charge a club that amount of money when clubs are scrapping for sponsors as is.