Would the result turn into a 3-0 win for cookers? If overturned.
Printable View
Would the result turn into a 3-0 win for cookers? If overturned.
Can someone from Morisset let us know something from your clubs perspective ....
I think we will let the process play out first......
this is basically the attitude of the moderation team - speculative nonsense will be deletedQuote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
Don't quote me, but I'm pretty sure I have read in the rules that a forfeit in either leg, forfeits the tie. If I am correct, that means there would be no res game tomorrow... that would be strange.Quote:
Originally Posted by controlzone
Sorry Boz just wanted Morisset to give their version of what has went down... Maybe they were informed from the association to late or maybe the referee report was filled out incorrectly ... That's all...
can everyone just check their facts before posting - otherwise posts will be deleted
e.g. Hotline - instead of saying 'you're pretty sure you read...' just go to the rules and regs for the competition on the Newcastle Football website and look them up - here they are http://newcastlefootball.com.au/file...ION_E_2015.pdf
then you can quote the regulation
E25 (f) In the event of a Team forfeiting a Finals Series Fixture, the Team will be
automatically disqualified from any further participation in the Finals Series
that may be open to interpretation and we'll still have to hold off judgement until we hear anything from the associations
We had a similar situation few seasons ago in zl3 against simba and that single game was overturned to a forfeit 3-0 win to us. That was the second leg of the finals. Id assume the same thing would happen here
It wouldn't be classed as a 2 leg forfeit, that rule would only be a proper forfeit I reckon, like not enough to field a team. I'd say it would be 3-0 same as simbaQuote:
Originally Posted by Wilso8948
Does that mean the player in question is now suspended for the 2nd leg? If so I hope they play him again and cookers progress. A few less loud mouth Morry fans at grand final day would be a blessing for all
I've seen on Fox Sports Pulse that the 1st grade Stockton v Morriset 1st leg reads 3-0 to Stockton
The plot thickens....
Sorry boz, will do next time.Quote:
Originally Posted by boz-monaut
The res result is still 4-0 to Morri though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Buddha
After the games and process go through I think we will respond. ...Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
What I will say is the above is pretty close to the truth.... in fact its very close
Heard via the grapevine that Charlie beat Warners Bay 3-1 in 3rd grade
Motown 2- 0 over Cookers
6-0 aggregate
But we will let the next few days play out to work out who is playing next weekend
Cooks Hill through due to 3-0 result from the first leg-Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
Appeal happening this week..... so not over just yetQuote:
Originally Posted by outsider
Never ever heard of a team loosing both semi finals but progressing... How proud Cookers must feel...Quote:
Originally Posted by outsider
The disappointing thing for Morisset is that now in hindsight the player in question was not needed... They should have just let him serve the ban regardless if the assoc informed them late or the ref said something to them after the kotara game... It's a shame for them cos they are a good team
To be clear - we rang the association and they said all our players were cleared - so not even late notification but notification in the positive (even the association agrees this is what they told us)Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
There are other issues as well but hey I have bit my tongue till now and I will continue to...
So at this current time Cooks Hill are through? If so I can't see you winning your appeal unfortunately.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
The ground announcer said Motown through on 6-0 aggregate. Because it was a somewhat confusing fixture would there have been extra time had Motown scored again or would the referees be officiating as if Motown were already 4-0 up?Quote:
Originally Posted by Beppe
So the 3-0 corrected result that was entered for 1sts in SP should have been entered for res?Quote:
Originally Posted by outsider
Why would Cooks Hill be proud ? wake up. what a cheap shot. Cookers have more silverware from legit efforts,that more than prove how proud we are as a successful club.Quote:
Originally Posted by GB285
Whats the real situation at the moment front2?Quote:
Originally Posted by front2
Sure but whilst we are on cheap shots your coach yelling out at the end of the game that we were cheats was a low blow as well... especially when the majority of cookers understood the situation and the agregate scoreQuote:
Originally Posted by front2
What was the score in 1st grade more importantly ?
How would you react if the opposition coach came to you at the end of the game and said 'you should be embarrassed that you are going through'Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
It's not the best situation for anyone but honestly morisset have no one to blame but their coaching staff for knowingly playing a suspended player. That was what everyone in the stands said too. You should stop blaming cookers, kotara, refs, association and blame the decision makers in your club that tried to knowingly skirt the rules. Regardless if the association said there wasn't a suspended player everyone in that team knew there was and played him anyway and ringing them to check if he could play is a clear admission of guilt in that you all knew he was suspended and were hoping you had got away with it.
Bay 1-0. Cookers on top early but missed chances, bay grabbed a counter and held out. Good luck to them next week, should be a good game vs mori or stockoQuote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
I'm guessing warners bay won firsts then?
Yep 4-1. They took their chances and that was the difference in the endQuote:
Originally Posted by Wilso8948
BTW Cooks Hill are not into cheap dumb ass decisions. Remember that time we beat Morisset in first grade GF at Edgey. FITH. ####silverwarebustincabinet##Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
Firstly we rang the association to check on all players -thats good management frankly something I would expect all teams would do. We had a suspended player in firsts and he did not play so I would say we hardly did it on purpose. .. if we did wouldn't we have also played him?Quote:
Originally Posted by WWMTD?
You guys couldn't score or even have one shot on target in 2 legs yet you are going through so do you deserve it... (yes you are going through but nearly every player from cookers said to me that we were the better team and deserve to go through but we know thats not how it stands)
Im not laying blame anywhere.... and its raw at the moment and you are going to get some comments like this... just accept it and move on because as it stands you guys are in the final...
Nope I rememeber 2009 when we beat you in the semi on the way to winning the final....Quote:
Originally Posted by front2
I don't think anyone is debating that mori were not the better team over 2 legs, the 6-0 score represents that. You guys have every right to be disappointed and angry but just place the anger where is it appropriate, not at the opposition and association and refs, but at the people in your club who decided that they had gotten away with a red card and could play a knowingly suspended playerQuote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
Quote:
Originally Posted by WWMTD?
"Knowingly" yet as jaypee has said, they rang association to check for all suspended players one came back and he sat out.. how is that knowingly playing a suspended player?
A red card in every league in the world is a mandatory week suspension. If it hadn't been processed through the fed someone from mo-town coaching staff surely had to say cop the week and once it comes through u have already served your suspension.
End of the day it's cost u guys a gf and the way you guys played the 2 legs possibly a gf gold medal
Jaypee admire the way you have conducted yourself on here.... I'm sure your shattered about the result of all this but really it was a silly risk to take ...
Yeah...and Merewether players (Papas inc) were lol'ing at us behind the goals losing that game and happy they were playing MoTown.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
That was the biggest larf I got outta that season in the end.
Cookers get a new gaffer in the next year and get to 5 straight GF's and win 4 of 'em.
Pretty much the same blokes who 2009 MoTown beat at Smith Pk (Yes, I was there on the BBQ....me ffs)
Btw front2, Cookers beat MoTown 1-2 in 2011. Inaugural ZLP season @ Wanderers. My klaxon got a work out that day.
Love fitbah history....