Today's results Valo v Charlestown
(having trouble with Sporting Pulse not allowing us to input results)
U13 1 - 1
U14 0 - 3 Charlestown win
U15 8 - 4 Valo win
U17 3 - 3
Printable View
Today's results Valo v Charlestown
(having trouble with Sporting Pulse not allowing us to input results)
U13 1 - 1
U14 0 - 3 Charlestown win
U15 8 - 4 Valo win
U17 3 - 3
Did Magic 17's stack the team with 19's players????? Must have..... Or am I wrong????
Didn't know NNSWF changed the rules to play 19 year olds in the U17's comp?
Implying that Magic always follow the rules.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Come on you know what I mean. Pull kids who normally play in 19's and are eligible to play17.
Kids who played in the team above last year
Most clubs have them, kids who are 16 or 17 this year playing 19s or higher.Quote:
Originally Posted by Doggydingo
Only those clubs who need to win everything play those kids down.
My mail is that Magic did precisely that on the weekend.
As last as the kids are getting a game who cares where they play, it's the attitudes of mums and dads that that creates win at all costs mentalities
But what about the kids registered in the 17s that are missing out on game time.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
Don't you forget the CLUB COMMITTEE also!Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
I've been told they were short of numbers and required the 19's to come back to help out till they get a few players.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wild Brew
But were the 19s sitting on the bench or the other 17s???Quote:
Originally Posted by Zico
You would think that they would push kids up instead to give them a challenging environment and further challenge/develop their younger players instead of chasing trophies.
Easy to blame mums and dads. Most only speak up when something dodgy is going on.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
That my point, it's all fine until mum and dad have a whinge, just let the kids play, they don't careQuote:
Originally Posted by early_to_the_match
They do if they spend most of the time sitting on the bench while an outsider takes their spot.Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverRed
We must have the same postman hamburgler !!! what I was told, in fact I was told stacked the 17'sQuote:
Originally Posted by hamburgler
Forever red......why always the parents ????
Wild brew .......correct
Doggy......even more correct
Zico......... Why not play 15's up ????
As hamburgler says most clubs have kids U17 in thier 19's yet it seems only magic played theirs ?????
Who cares!!! Any team's that had the misfortune to play Magic U17's in preseason and had the game called off because Magic U17's had 5-7 players out injured and couldnt field a team no-one complained then... how many U17/U19's's for Magic were on the bench for Magic Last weekend? 1 player? I applaud the kids who can play down and choose to help out there club that may be going through a tough time with injuries!!!
Look out here comes the magic PR deptQuote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Let's cut the crap here this is not short term
Fact magic lost nearly 1/2 of kids from 2015 youth program
U17 squad is down to 9 and coach gone!!!
Magic madly ringing kids they rejected initially now telling them Magic is were they need to be, tip to magic.....kids talk, so when you ring kids with your bs offering , the kids know the truth.
Truth is that magic youth program is a shambles at the moment
And we still WON!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
If that's so important to youQuote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Yes in the grade you stacked
No others !!!!!!!
Stack Smack... don't be upset if your prima-donnas refuse to help out your club's lower grades... its Youth Football, expecting more players to come off the injured list in the next few weeks... You just worry about keeping the cockroaches out of the chip cups at Lisle Carr.Quote:
Originally Posted by Why Blue
I've got no comeback to that !!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Except
Go magic go magic go magic go magic go magic repeat 100 times
:popcorn:
Put your popcorn awayQuote:
Originally Posted by GO AWAY
Obviously magician and I look for different things from a club
I would rather know were the cockroaches are !!!!!!
Any scores from today?
HOFC PS4 NPL NNSW Youth Results Round 2 | Olympic vs Charlestown
Under 17s Olympic won 4-1
Under 15s Olympic won 3-1
Under 14s Olympic won 3-1
Under 13s Olympic won 6-0
Arrive back from holidays, and things have spiced up. Gentlemen The Magician is correct and has point, these so called stacked players are the correct age, and have the option to play in 17's.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
However the 2 football points i raise-
1) These stacked players, have played up for many years in the jets, refusing to play in there correct age groups,however it seems the novelty now to play down, raises questions have they finally realised they are more suited and can dominate in there correct age group,rather then playing up in the 19's and 22's competition as there are.
or simply
2) The current 17's team, are just poor, and need assistance to win games- so as long as players and parents are satisfied with little Timmy warming benches for others, thats also fine.
i dont see a problem either way.
garbage creedQuote:
Originally Posted by Apollo Creed
play the team selected at trials
If I was a parent paying big money for my son to play & he is selected in a squad & then left picking splinters out of his pants because players selected in another squad were picked instead of my boy I'm pretty sure I'd have a good old dummy spit.Quote:
Originally Posted by Apollo Creed
Do the Youth League have interchange for all age groups & is there a criteria that all players over the course of the season must play 50/60% game time.
So how many Magic 19s played down this week? Wonder how the 15s parents and players feels seeing potential opportunity to fill in for 17s go to an older ex jets 19s player?Quote:
Originally Posted by Apollo Creed
Think I know the answer to that question, but as long as Magic keep winning then all good!
Actually thought Magic 17s looked ok, with or without their 19/22s. If not for a player being red carded they would have won by more. And the Buds have shown to be a side that should be contesting the back end of the season.
I did hear that Magic had a new coach?
Why Blue? can you confirm if Charlestown U17's were deducted points from their first round match vs Valentine for fielding unregistered players? Naughty Naughty!
Magician, would have no clue, pretty stupid if they have but then again as a club CCB can do some pretty stupid thingsQuote:
Originally Posted by The Magician
Original result for Valo v Charlestown was 3 - 3. It is now listed as a 3 nil win to Valentine, the result they give for a forfeited match. So no doubt they have been penalised.
The joys of "senior elite" competitions vs interdistrict teams.
Little johny isn't guaranteed to play every game for his money. If he's good enough, or knows somebody, he will play. If he's not one of the best 11, well, wait for your chance and make the most of it.
If you were one of the better players, and you were benched, to give donkey johnny a game so his daddy didn't get mad, you'd be a bit pissed off. It's preseason for NPL seniors, so maybe they are getting some games under their belt for the eligible players.
Senior football.
Some clubs will cater for development and some will want to win. You make your choice when you choose the club.
Correct me if im wrong but didn't the the magician in an earlier post say Magic 17s had some long term injuries and it wasn't so much that U19s were playing down but more to the point U19s were making up the numbers and no U17 player was being disadvantaged. If thats the case credit to the guys who are stepping down to lend the club a handQuote:
Originally Posted by Tonester
Well what Magician says may not always be the case.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stanley
Not just 19s but 22s filling in. Sure they may be eligible on age, but all clubs have 17s registered to play in older age groups, and when short normally bring up from 15s. And where were those older kids when Magic 17s forfeited 4 trial games? I don't think any kid was prepared to play down in 17s until their coach left.
So called elite youth teams = $$$$>Ability
Some clubs will do anything to win
That's all