plus side, no malik next week!
Printable View
plus side, no malik next week!
Rough call.
What happened to that whole directive about penalties and red/yellow cards?
I don’t think the tackle was horrendously bad. Contact points weren’t great but I thi I it was a legitimate attempt on the ball.
Wonder if Milligan red card got reviewed?
How often to you see players size each their up and come together to a yellow or a stern chat.
For Milligan, it did say up on the screen there was a VAR review while he was waking off the field.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
As soon as Milligan made contact with DG leading with his head the ref had no choice but to show him the red. Milligan must have thought for a second there he was Alex Brosque and immune to being sent off.
:rof:Quote:
Originally Posted by The Dunster
Malik ripped right off. Maybe only just a pen, never red.
The people operating this need to be better and not scared of sydney
I dont get why they call the ref over to make a decision. Commentators said last night that the ref made the call after viewing. If we are going to use such a pointless system make the var make the call and get on with the game. Not review it then get the ref to review it and make a decision.
i don't really have a problem with the red card. it was tough, yes, but it was late, he slid in studs up, he got him.
i can't remember anything in the rules about "intent to injure" being required for a red. players should be more careful, tackles like that can end careers.
i assume it is required to make sure that the on-field ref still has the greatest authority.Quote:
Originally Posted by westjet
plus, it's what the NFL does, and everything American sport related is the best ever.
Watching the replay and hearing Speedy yelling out "they have to look at that on the Maccas VAR surely".
It was meant to be seamless but its being constantly referred about.
Yeh he is terrible for it too. I’d imagine Maccas want some sort of return for their investment.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jetmaster
Simon Hill has mentioned on podcasts that they might as well draw “the Golden Arches” in the air instead of the 3rd umpire style box
no way.Quote:
Originally Posted by belchardo
The initial lunge was at the ball and the opposing player was sliding into a position where his feet were going. That tackle was ending nothing
https://www.foxsports.com.au/footbal...2813b84bb57067
What about that VAR Member?.... FFS... #SFCKhunts
Roar handball accidently and concede a penalty. Sfc handball 4 times so far and ref is yet to blow whistle. Then you have sfc chopping down players and again ni whistle. Roar on the other hand get penalised for minimal contact.
Can'tvwait to beat these khunts in thre finals
How long did it take to make that send off decision? 5 minutes?
Let's see how much stoppage time we get.
yep, five full minutes and they didn't seem to look at the angle that showed the gob didn't land on the ****
who here wouldn't gob on Matt Simon if you ever got within gobbing distance
gobbing distance meaning you're either in a crack den or a centrelink office yeah?Quote:
Originally Posted by boz-monaut
Out of the country stillQuote:
Originally Posted by lquiquer
Ain't wasting time watching the Smurfs play
Love the bit how you said finals and we not even taking the pissQuote:
Originally Posted by The Dunster
It just an automated acceptance that it will occur
Ohh how times have changed
This is getting ridiculous....and is causing more grief and anger than no VAR. Pen given way after play has carried on and why the red card for handball like that?
Kudos to Simon Hill for calling to end the whole charade.