Murphy out

[la bazzle]

^winner

[stopper2]

As I was leaving the game last night, I am 99% sure that I walked past Murphy sitting alone in Bay 58. He actually looked very serious and an almost despondent looking figure sitting all alone.

[Jeterpool]

As I was leaving the game last night, I am 99% sure that I walked past Murphy sitting alone in Bay 58. He actually looked very serious and an almost despondent looking figure sitting all alone.

He was up in the box between 58 and 59 during the game

[MFKS]

He was up in the box between 58 and 59 during the game

Was he still there when people were given Stubbins a spray.

I ****ing hope so??

[lquiquer]

If that Murphy bloke was the #St8shooter some of you claim he is, his first job would have been to sack Mr 1 in 20..... The bloke is Tinks' Muppet....... He talks rubbish, just repeat what Singapore boy tells him to say.... #MovingBackward

[BodyNovo]

If that Murphy bloke was the #St8shooter some of you claim he is, his first job would have been to sack Mr 1 in 20..... The bloke is Tinks' Muppet....... He talks rubbish, just repeat what Singapore boy tells him to say.... #MovingBackward

I reckon if 1 and 20 is 1 and 27 i don't think he will be around

His show cause period is now

[Hunter403]

Anyone else hear this spin doctor on the ABC radio this morning. Talks like a politician and about as believable

"Phil needs the chance to select his own team"
"We are understrength"
"Like a lot of Newcastle businesses we have some problems with cash flow".

Tinkler's mouth piece. Another Muppet

The only positive was a hint that if we don't start strongly next season then Phil could be in trouble

[Bon]

Anyone else hear this spin doctor on the ABC radio this morning. Talks like a politician and about as believable

"Phil needs the chance to select his own team"
"We are understrength"
"Like a lot of Newcastle businesses we have some problems with cash flow".

Tinkler's mouth piece. Another Muppet

The only positive was a hint that if we don't start strongly next season then Phil could be in trouble

So frustrating...
Then even if we do get rid of the Stubborn prick, we will get another season of bollocks, followed by more excuses like "I didn't choose this team" and yet ANOTHER year of rebuilding..

[Grimario]

Anyone else hear this spin doctor on the ABC radio this morning. Talks like a politician and about as believable

"Phil needs the chance to select his own team"
"We are understrength"
"Like a lot of Newcastle businesses we have some problems with cash flow".

Tinkler's mouth piece. Another Muppet

The only positive was a hint that if we don't start strongly next season then Phil could be in trouble

Shambles.

[Premy]

Madaschi
Celeski
Steele
Neuman
Flores
Welsh
Gallagher
Montano
Caravella

Mullen
Ki-je
Enver
Vanstraten
Cooper

He got the squad he wanted this season, what makes them think that he won't make the same mistakes next season

[Jeterpool]

Madaschi
Celeski
Steele
Neuman
Flores
Welsh
Gallagher
Montano
Caravella

Mullen
Ki-je
Enver
Vanstraten
Cooper

He got the squad he wanted this season, what makes them think that he won't make the same mistakes next season

The only ones we can say for certain are the last 5 and probably Welsh? Who knows if the previous hierarchy "forced" them onto Phil.

[lquiquer]

The only ones we can say for certain are the last 5 and probably Welsh? Who knows if the previous hierarchy "forced" them onto Phil.

Previous hierarchy didn't have the balls to force Phil into anything ......Was his squad (And he re-signed Carney).

[Nou Camp]

The only positive was a hint that if we don't start strongly next season then Phil could be in trouble

how could it even get to the point of him starting next season

[GazFish35]

regardless of whos squad it is/was at the start of the season is was better than 1 win.

atht alone suggests he doesnt deserve the chance to rebuild.


well be shit after 5 weeks next year, sack him and the next bloke gets to use the "it wasnt my squad" excuse for another season.



sack him now.

[Bon]

regardless of whos squad it is/was at the start of the season is was better than 1 win.

atht alone suggests he doesnt deserve the chance to rebuild.


well be shit after 5 weeks next year, sack him and the next bloke gets to use the "it wasnt my squad" excuse for another season.



sack him now.

Exactly..

[Jetmaster]

Previous hierarchy didn't have the balls to force Phil into anything ......Was his squad (And he re-signed Carney).

See my summary of the interview in the news thread....the indication from Murphy was that Middelby and Baartz brought in the players and that it had been happening for some time. I hope it goes up on Soundcloud.

[Jeterpool]

Previous hierarchy didn't have the balls to force Phil into anything ......Was his squad (And he re-signed Carney).

See my summary of the interview in the news thread....the indication from Murphy was that Middelby and Baartz brought in the players and that it had been happening for some time. I hope it goes up on Soundcloud.

Thanks JM. Premy, this was what I based my post on, as the same thing was said to us b Murphy at the committee meeting. It's a case of he said/she said and while they may have been signed while stubbins was coach, it doesn't mean he had control in signing them...not does it mean he didn't.

I think we can now say, though, Stubbins certainly signed Mullen, Le-Ki, Cooper, JV Stratten and Alivodic. Two of these have been any sort of success, two haven't been used and one the jury is out on in my opinion.

[Jeterpool]

regardless of whos squad it is/was at the start of the season is was better than 1 win.

atht alone suggests he doesnt deserve the chance to rebuild.


well be shit after 5 weeks next year, sack him and the next bloke gets to use the "it wasnt my squad" excuse for another season.



sack him now.

Exactly..

Agree. But maybe, just maybe, we get a coach who doesn't use this excuse and can motivate players to perform next year.

However, if he's still here next year I can hear the excuses for a early FFA cup exit "The team needs time to bed in after such a massive overhaul of the squad last year and develop the mentality I want from the side and play the football that I want". Followed by a slow start to the season with "I'm happy with the performances and we're getting close to a win. Once the team get to know each other and work how I want them to, we'll see better performances".

Followed by the inevitable sacking midseason of players.

[lquiquer]

Thanks JM. Premy, this was what I based my post on, as the same thing was said to us b Murphy at the committee meeting. It's a case of he said/she said and while they may have been signed while stubbins was coach, it doesn't mean he had control in signing them...not does it mean he didn't.

Of course Murphy is going to tell you that. Would be interested to know what Middleby and Baartz have to say.....

[Jeterpool]

Of course Murphy is going to tell you that. Would be interested to know what Middleby and Baartz have to say.....

As would I mate, as would I. I'm not buying it all either, however without concrete facts we can only use what we're told. The rest is unfounded speculation.