The endless (and probably pointless) GK debate thread.

[GazFish35]

Here here mate!

So over this bitchin' between supporters of who is better.
Mate rings me about 8.30pm last night, wasn't at the game or didn't see it on FOX but heard how Birraz come out and didn't punch the ball clearly. Next few minutes get a spiel of how BK is better and how Birraz is still too immature.....blah blah.
Vidmar called Adelaide a pissant town, reckon Newcastle would go close to being one too!

No ones arguing about whose the better keeper. We're all in agreeance.

It's the double standards in analyzing their games that generates the 50 odd pages.

[MFKS]

51 pages on a position that isnt a real problem. so jets

To me it is a problem. We are paying our reserve keeper over 100k to sit on his arse each week waiting for one of our keepers to have his head kicked in before he gets a run. FFS we only get to play against Smeltz 3 x a year

Money that could be better spent on paying a rookie as our back up keeper and signing someone else further up the park with a bit more quality than what we have

[hawk]

well x that by 100 and thats how much of a problem we have with those other cvnts in front of him

[stopper2]

No ones arguing about whose the better keeper. We're all in agreeance.

It's the double standards in analyzing their games that generates the 50 odd pages.

So it's basically like the Reclaim Australia mob and the Lefty's in that both groups are feeding off each others shit!

[RAM]

Good to see ol' Flappy McDropdrop come out and cost us another goal on the weekend.

Until we have a keeper that can catch a cross, FK or corner under pressure we will continue to concede soft and costly goals.

[RAM]

Also just watching it again there were 4 dickheads in gold and one gypo in the contest for the ball with Birraz.

What the **** are 4 of them doing going for a ball their keeper is going for FFS???


One of the four was responsible for leaving the goal scorer free and the another was responsible for leaving the bloke who provided the assist free.

Amateur defending FFS

Did he call for it? If not you can't complain about them trying to clear the ball.

[plague]

Good to see ol' Flappy McDropdrop come out and cost us another goal on the weekend.

If the other 10 Mongs on the park only made one mistake per game we'd be top of the league fahkern.

[Jetmaster]

Unfortunately, that is the downside for us keepers....we make one mistake and get crucified. It has to phase you and you have to man up. BK cops it too.
Flappa and the Flapbois should admit to a technical weakness. Stop sweeping it under the carpet.

[hawk]

this thread continues to deliver

[RAM]

Unfortunately, that is the downside for us keepers....we make one mistake and get crucified. It has to phase you and you have to man up. BK cops it too.
Flappa and the Flapbois should admit to a technical weakness. Stop sweeping it under the carpet.

yep

any opposition coach should be targetting ol' flappy

[q-money]

how about izzo clattering into all the defenders? awful refereeing as usual.

[GazFish35]

how about izzo clattering into all the defenders? awful refereeing as usual.

that was BK's fault

[belchardo]

that was BK's fault

now, now. no need to say things like that.















everybody know's everything is BK's fault.

[RAM]

how about izzo clattering into all the defenders? awful refereeing as usual.

wasn't a foul, bloke was just going up for a header

Birra's fault 100%

[q-money]

come on, it's an awful attempt, almost superman punches the ball in himself

[RAM]

come on, it's an awful attempt, almost superman punches the ball in himself

dreaming

watched it a few times - no foul on Birra or any of our players

Birra's lack of presence in the box cost us another 3 points.

[GazFish35]

dreaming

watched it a few times - no foul on Birra or any of our players

Birra's lack of presence in the box cost us another 3 points.

Hyperbole much!

it cost us 2 pts, not 3

[belchardo]

dreaming

watched it a few times - no foul on Birra or any of our players

Birra's lack of presence in the box cost us another 3 points.

no foul? you reckon any other player on the field would have got away with that "challenge"? he took out 3 players!

[RAM]

Hyperbole much!

it cost us 2 pts, not 3

meh, he's a liability in the air

[RAM]

no foul? you reckon any other player on the field would have got away with that "challenge"? he took out 3 players!

Only saw 1 go down

was merely contesting the header