REFEREE Ben Williams and at least one of his assistants could be dumped this week after their boss admitted they had made critical mistakes during Central Coast's controversial 2-1 loss to Newcastle on Saturday.
While newly appointed Football Federation Australia director of referees Ben Wilson refused to be drawn on the immediate future of the match officials, he told The Australian there was no escaping the fact they had got at least three of four contentious rulings wrong during the spiteful F3 Derby.
His admission came as Mariners chairman Peter Turnbull called for the introduction of a captain's referral system.
Turnbull believes "it is about time for a review system" after the Mariners went behind to a penalty then had a last-minute goal disallowed.
"It is no point pretending technology is not in our sport. If we really did not allow technology, we'd still be wearing ankle-choker boots and wearing heavy woollen jerseys and using lace-up leather balls,"he said.
Mariners coach Graham Arnold was quietly seething over Williams's failure to send off Jets midfielder Ruben Zadkovic in the first minute of the match for a studs up tackle, and an offside that went against Josh Rose.
Arnold did not want to discuss the situation yesterday, but he described Williams's effort as "pretty average" during the post-match conference. "I will probably get called a whinger, but the incidents that happened in the first five minutes turned the match," Arnold said.
Wilson, who recently replaced former referees boss Mark Shield, said there was no question Zadkovic should have been red carded, that the Emile Heskey penalty decision was incorrect and that the assistant referee should not have flagged Rose offside.
"The clubs have asked the referees to concentrate on the safety of the players," Wilson said. "In Zadkovic's case, the player's safety was endangered by that tackle and he should have been sent off. Whether it was the first minute or the 90th, those sort of tackles have to be punished with a red card."
Former England international Heskey was awarded a penalty four minutes later after a collision with Michael McGlinchey.
"That decision was incorrect," Wilson said. "The contact was minimal and Heskey probably played for the penalty. The referee wasn't well positioned and it was a harsh decision."
Not long after that goal, Rose was ruled offside after he raced on to a pass and was left in open space with several teammates in support. "There is no defending that ruling, unfortunately," Wilson said. "The assistant referee was well positioned but he was focusing on the wrong player (Daniel McBreen). Rose came from well inside his own half."
Wilson said disallowing Patrick Zwaanswijk's goal for offside was right, but he conceded it could have gone either way and that the assistant referee would "not have been marked down for putting his flag up or down".
"Finally some good news," he quipped. "The player had his foot or leg off side, so it was a correct ruling, but our guys are instructed to give the benefit of the doubt to the attacking team."
Wilson said it was too early to decide if Williams and his assistants would get games this weekend. "I will look at the official match inspector's report in the next day or two and that will be compared to our elite coach, who will also do an assessment through what he has seen on the videos," he said.
That match aside, Wilson was delighted with the overall performances of his match officials.
"The first two rounds have seen some great entertainment and the referees have not been spoken about," he said.
As for the captain's referral, Wilson is not in favour of it because "it isn't foolproof and as you have seen in other sports you probably get as many contentious decisions coming from the video referee's box as you would from referees".