Why punish an obviously talented footballer. it's not their fault their elite program collapsed, all they were doing was playing football. These kids were probably ecstatic, they were playing for their local a league team. We should be praising these kids for aiming high (questionable, but in theory playing for an a league clubs junior team should be an honour) as there are many who can't be bothered or weren't selected (some right or wrongly). Sending them to an A-grade competition simply to "teach their parents a lesson" is absolutely ridiculous, and your intentions are hypocritical. Regardless of your views of the emerging jets program, punishing the emerging jets players by holding back their development just to teach their mum or dad a lesson is frankly appalling. Yes, there were questionable methods in selective teams, and a range of negatives surrounding the process and bang-for-buck value of the program, but all these kids want to do I play football and succeed. That's why they turn up to train 3-4 times a week and games all throughout their summer and onto season proper, they are committed to being the best they can be. You have a few players quitting the Jets youth program because
they can't commit to the schedule.
Ethically and morally, yes, the clubs should be honouring their commitment to the players they have selected. Replacing them, would be wrong I agree. Unethically, the clubs are simply trying to get the best 14 or so players into their team/club.
What should happen? NNSW and Jets and other stakeholders, should commit to the 2015 season as they are well and truly underway. Anything else and these players are disadvantaged and they shouldn't be punished for believing in themselves and the promises of EJ.