How many wbay players will Cardiff be able to fit in their squad? Could be an opportunity for some other teams to pick up some handy players for next season.
Printable View
How many wbay players will Cardiff be able to fit in their squad? Could be an opportunity for some other teams to pick up some handy players for next season.
How's about we reserve judgement until after the weekend. Warners Bay have slipped under the radar all year. They've always been written off. They're one of only a couple to beat Morry this year (even though there was a send off). There's a reason they're there on the final day. I have no doubt they'll put on a good showing this coming weekend.
Tall bald guy upfront is vital for Warners Bay to have a chance of beating Morriset - he a good player
I agree that if duncan isnt kept quite then it will be an interesting game.Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
West lakes, the good guys of the league. :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by ICEBERG10
Sporting Pulse has Reserve Grade GF...... KOTARA v COOKS HILL
Is this another sporting Pulse gaff - or has it now been locked in
Being Wednesday today would surely have to be decision time
As I have said before a red card is an automatic one week suspension without appeal.How could Morisset even think they could be in the GF-they knew that the player was sent off and chose to play him the next week.Appeal should not even be considered by the association as it is contrary to Regulation G Clause 15.1b which covers the issue of red cards.Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
Ahhh but it says this as well - As per the Laws of the Game as proscribed and issued by FIFA from time to time, the Chairperson of the Disciplinary Committee shall follow the following guidelinesQuote:
Originally Posted by outsider
It was the Chairperson of said committee that stated the player was free to play......
Look lets just let an outcome be decided and move on..... whatever way it falls....
I wonder what the cooks hill players think about the whole situation? Do they think they were robbed in the first game and the 6-0 result wasn't a fair reflection of the tie or have they conceded that they have just picked up a get out of jail free card?
Id suggest that the player did not have much of an impact - played left back...Quote:
Originally Posted by Bench warmer
To be honest we should have scored 6 last weekend alone so it should be a non issue.
I would suggest the score line was a fair reflection - over two legs not one shot on target....
I dont think anyone would suggest they were robbed
Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
So can the Chairperson overide the regulations.There is no issue regarding the red card-suspended one match-everyone knew the player had been sent off-
A fairer outcome may have been 3-0 win CH then play the 2nd leg. Morri would have then known what they needed to do next week.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
It's is sometimes difficult to work out who each person on here's allegiances lie with, but not much has come out about cooks hill beingthrilled about heading into a grand final on the back of 6-0 thumping. Correct me if I'm wrong but many of the people hammering Morry the hardest are with kotara, so I'm sure they would rather play a limping cooks hill as opposed to a fired up MotownQuote:
Originally Posted by Bench warmer
And from what I hear 4 of those were reserve graders. Disarray. Morry are a sure thing this wknd. That wasn't their coach yielding a knife at the bay the sarv was itQuote:
Originally Posted by The Spy
In what competition can you get a red card and not receive a suspension?
I have no allegiances whatsoever but I feel like anybody that's ever played football is aware that a red card means a suspension.
Feel sorry for the players. But really, what do you expect?
When you contacted the fed, did you tell them one of your players was sent off and the ask if they can play? Or was it deliberately circumventing the integrity of the competition?
It's round 1, player gets a red card, do you play him in round 2? Of course not. Why is this any different.
I'm not 100% sure of the way the judiciary works but is it different with yellow cards if they don't inform you of when the suspension is due are you not required to take it until you are notified?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremsstrahlung
Never played with Zone Leagues but I know with NPL and I assume NEWFM, it is the club's responsibility to keep track of these. There is a delay with official processing of teamsheets and cards and then getting the information out to clubs in time, as far as i'm aware.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nave
Nave, I play for kotara ressies and don't care who we play...our side is of the same opinion... Have had great games against both teams and I'm sure Saturday will be another great game against whatever team we play
But it's Wednesday now and both teams involved in the GF should know what's goin on - more so Morisset and Cooks Hill if it's goin to be one or the other
Surely you've got to be happier playing a team that's down on form and down on confidenceQuote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
Doesn't matter it's a GF and It's irrelevant who I want to play all I'm saying is that the association should stop all this speculation and just say...decision made the GF is Kotara v one of these sides and we can all can get on with it
Out of interest. Were cookers/the association tipped off prior to the post on this forum? Or has this all literally come from this thread?
Just wondering how this has been policed in reality, rather than watching it play out over the internet.
This would be pure speculation but here goesQuote:
Originally Posted by Cabaye#4
I would suggest Kotara players raised the initial question on the forum, Cookers were actively encouraged by forum users to approach the association - either they did or a member on here from the association did...
Its been policed poorly (regardless of what side you sit on) - making a decision at 3pm on the Friday before the second leg was poorly timed....
Being relatively close in proximity some of our players know some of their players and they share match reports. Simple as that.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
One of our guys mentioned that we beat mori and their captain got sent off.
Pretty sure this is where it all started on the forum ..... - and I am not pointing fingers here - the original question asked if it started on the forum or elsewhere - perhaps its a bit of bothQuote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
yep i asked the question...... shoot me
Nah mate - was just answering the question....Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
I wonder if kotara or cooks Hill would have brought it up if morisset had lost?
Who cares? What's done is done. What's the point in making Kotara look like the bad guys? They didn't play an illegible player.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bench warmer
We need someone to cheer for and against on SaturdayQuote:
Originally Posted by namwob99
My point being that if it was only brought to light due to the forums, then it really does put the honus on the clubs to self police, and thus Mori dug their own hole. You can't claim ignorance after the fact only because it was brought to light. This isn't the big leagues, there is some honesty required to maintain the integrity of the competition.Quote:
Originally Posted by C'mon man
I guess we felt we did the right thing - we asked the chairperson of the discipline committee who was and who was not eligible to play.... (we certainly were not trying to cheat - he is the most obvious looking player and we played him under his real name)Quote:
Originally Posted by Cabaye#4
As I said in another post we should have put enough goals in last weekend and none of it would have been an issue....
If I was asked who was and was not eligible I would assume you were talking about yellow card tally. If the question was we had a player sent off last week is he eligible to play this weekend? Then surely the answer would be no.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
I honestly just cannot fathom why you would even think you could play a player that was sent off in the previous game.
What was the outcome of this?
Was the chairperson specifically asked about the player who was sent off? Or was a broad question asked, where the chairperson may not have been aware of the situation as yet?Quote:
Originally Posted by jaypee
This is exactly how the chairperson probably received the question. Who was suspended (based on yellows), because the clubs should know who is suspended from receiving red cards. Automatic one week and a letter to be sent if more.Quote:
Originally Posted by Happy Tiger
Its all speculation from here guys as none of us where on the calls.... the issues happened we have a lost a GF spot over it.....(assuming the decision won't be changed).....
I don't blame Kotara or Cookers at all - I'm pretty sure all clubs would have done the same thing.... and if it had been another club I am sure I would be saying the same thing everyone else is here....
NOW...
Can we all move ahead now and look forward to the weekend....
Hot tip just in
Warnesbay to win 3-1
Good luck to all teams this weekend great achievement
Enjoy
1st: Bay 3-2
2nd: Kotara 2-0
3rd: Kotara 4-1
Mori 3-1
Kotara 3-1
Kotara 2-0
1sts: 2-2 in reg time, with Mori to grab a winner in extra time
Res: Kotara 2-0, Cooks Hill shocking over two legs in the semis, Kotara very solid at the back across both legs in the semi, although left alot to be desired in the front third especially with Clear Cut chances
3rds: Kotara 3-1, Kotara to totally dominate this but concede an own goal