Quote Originally Posted by AVB View Post
I think we need to stop blaming the individual clubs for this and start considering that there may be greater issues at play here that need addressing such as the competitiveness of the competitions.

I'm sure all clubs are doing their absolute best to attract players in all age groups but if there aren’t enough players interested in playing then what can clubs do? Anyone who thinks that clubs not fielding teams has anything to do with the club not working hard enough or not prioritising it enough simply wrong.

The u16s age group is clearly the biggest example here - 3 teams in the NL1 and 1 team in the NPL haven’t been able to field a team. Anecdotally there was a few clubs who were struggling in NPL to fill their u16s team until Cooks Hill withdrew and the players they had were redistributed. Everyone’s favourite example of the best NL1 club New Lambton have even been advertising his week for players for their u16s team, so they can't be flush either.

To NNSW credit they have clearly identified issues here as well and are engaging clubs on how to restructure the Youth grades across the board to make it more competitive.
One of the biggest problems I see is that every year we see large numbers of teams being taken from NL1 into NPL. But the kids being dropped from NPL aren't going back to NL1 teams. Some do but plenty either go to another sport or go to community because they have just spent the past year losing to 3/4 of teams by a lot.

Hopefully this decoupling will ensure that clubs that are struggling in NPL will now face equal competition and enjoy the game because they win or if they lose it isn't by 7-8 goals every week and will keep players in the game allowing other clubs to start filling up their teams.

If one of these teams that do get dropped to a lower division start improving then ensure there is promotion/relegation to bump them up and get tested against tougher teams. No point in splitting up the comp to not have promotion and relegation to just go back to the same issues we have now