Out of interest. Were cookers/the association tipped off prior to the post on this forum? Or has this all literally come from this thread?
Just wondering how this has been policed in reality, rather than watching it play out over the internet.
Out of interest. Were cookers/the association tipped off prior to the post on this forum? Or has this all literally come from this thread?
Just wondering how this has been policed in reality, rather than watching it play out over the internet.
When I grow up, I want to be Yohan Cabaye.
This would be pure speculation but here goesOriginally Posted by Cabaye#4
I would suggest Kotara players raised the initial question on the forum, Cookers were actively encouraged by forum users to approach the association - either they did or a member on here from the association did...
Its been policed poorly (regardless of what side you sit on) - making a decision at 3pm on the Friday before the second leg was poorly timed....
Being relatively close in proximity some of our players know some of their players and they share match reports. Simple as that.
One of our guys mentioned that we beat mori and their captain got sent off.
Pretty sure this is where it all started on the forum ..... - and I am not pointing fingers here - the original question asked if it started on the forum or elsewhere - perhaps its a bit of both
yep i asked the question...... shoot me
Nah mate - was just answering the question....
I wonder if kotara or cooks Hill would have brought it up if morisset had lost?
Who cares? What's done is done. What's the point in making Kotara look like the bad guys? They didn't play an illegible player.
We need someone to cheer for and against on Saturday
My point being that if it was only brought to light due to the forums, then it really does put the honus on the clubs to self police, and thus Mori dug their own hole. You can't claim ignorance after the fact only because it was brought to light. This isn't the big leagues, there is some honesty required to maintain the integrity of the competition.
When I grow up, I want to be Yohan Cabaye.
I guess we felt we did the right thing - we asked the chairperson of the discipline committee who was and who was not eligible to play.... (we certainly were not trying to cheat - he is the most obvious looking player and we played him under his real name)
As I said in another post we should have put enough goals in last weekend and none of it would have been an issue....
If I was asked who was and was not eligible I would assume you were talking about yellow card tally. If the question was we had a player sent off last week is he eligible to play this weekend? Then surely the answer would be no.
My views and opinions are my own. My club excepts no responsibility for what I may say or do.
I honestly just cannot fathom why you would even think you could play a player that was sent off in the previous game.
What was the outcome of this?
Was the chairperson specifically asked about the player who was sent off? Or was a broad question asked, where the chairperson may not have been aware of the situation as yet?
This is exactly how the chairperson probably received the question. Who was suspended (based on yellows), because the clubs should know who is suspended from receiving red cards. Automatic one week and a letter to be sent if more.
Its all speculation from here guys as none of us where on the calls.... the issues happened we have a lost a GF spot over it.....(assuming the decision won't be changed).....
I don't blame Kotara or Cookers at all - I'm pretty sure all clubs would have done the same thing.... and if it had been another club I am sure I would be saying the same thing everyone else is here....
NOW...
Can we all move ahead now and look forward to the weekend....
Hot tip just in
Warnesbay to win 3-1
Good luck to all teams this weekend great achievement
Enjoy
1st: Bay 3-2
2nd: Kotara 2-0
3rd: Kotara 4-1
Mori 3-1
Kotara 3-1
Kotara 2-0
1sts: 2-2 in reg time, with Mori to grab a winner in extra time
Res: Kotara 2-0, Cooks Hill shocking over two legs in the semis, Kotara very solid at the back across both legs in the semi, although left alot to be desired in the front third especially with Clear Cut chances
3rds: Kotara 3-1, Kotara to totally dominate this but concede an own goal
Jaliens gives me the horn
Posting Permissions
