Westy picked up a few boys that went back there after being at Barnsley, didn't make em much better.
The boys from Charlestown to dudley were lower grade players as were the boys from Lambton to mayfield. I heard cooks hill were ok but never seen em.
My original point was that Even if these teams were a little better or around the same it wouldn't make the comp better.
By adding 5 teams in there of equal quality as bel swans than that's the only way the comp would be better.
We might have to find 4 teams as good as magic as well to make NBN better, get rid of the jets, valo, lakes and Charlestown.
Promotion and relegation is the only way to reward a team that won the comp and if ya last down you go, this way cooks hill, Barnsley, uni etc know what they need to do to go up.
What ever you do you will never have a comp that is fully Even, NEVER.
Is the premier league Even?
Is the A league Even?
As I'm not on any competitions side I do feel for sides like cooks hill that want to go up, but take ya fight up with northern, stop bagging the clubs who are there.
Some very fair points there! No league is even.
It is about trying to make football better quality in each division...
I agree just straight up promotion and relegation is the way to go to make any competition stronger. Surely it would pretty much even out, the teams with the best facilities and such would work there way to the top, as the would have the money to do so.
WE DON'T DO WALKING AWAY !
Thornton V Adamstown tonight , but does not kick off till 8pm !!! I always think its better for the crowd if 1st grade play before 23s or 19s on catch up games as it can often lead to more people going along to the match.
Still big night for the buds so the scarf and coat at the ready and off to Thornton we go.... i might even treat the wife to a night out.. Anyone recommend any nice pubs or restaurants to eat Thornton way ?
I said consistently beat.... any team can win a one off game. By the way there is a big difference in watching teams and thinking they can beat teams and playing and beating.
You speak about Dudley....they were in New FM a few years ago ....where did they come again.
I don't doubt that the teams you mentioned could beat Singleton etc.., but would they finish the comp in any better position than Singleton
So if a team was to go through a season and lose most games say 1-0, 2-1, 3-1 or something... you would say the league is the same quality as if it had a team getting beaten 11-0?
I honestly do no believe that Adamstown would beat pretty much any ZPL team by that margin. Yes they would probably still win and the table may be similar to now, but would the standard be better?
Dudley was a few years ago, i am unsure of how they went... it has nothing to do with my point that i think they or others (more so cooks hill and uni) would be a bigger challenge than a team like singo this year.
WE DON'T DO WALKING AWAY !
Don't forget there are some quality players running around in these teams out of the top 4 its just unfortunate 2 or 3 players don't make up for the rest of the team.
ive seen maitland play singleton a few times and by no means do some of the results they are on the receiving end of reflect on how capable they are. id imagine as the season kicks on for them the motivation drops and the scorelines rise as they find themselves stuck at the bottom of the table.
this would be the same across most divisions id imagine.
but hey we still see 4 or 5 goal results still in NBN so what do you say there.
regardless of teams coming in or out ur still gonna see the big split between top 3 or 4 teams its just the way it is and has been now for a number of years
money talks to much to most players these days so the clubs with the money to spend usually get the players and results
if you were Adamstown with the players you have you would be dissapointed not to be scoring 5+ against most teams
iirc there was a 16-1 scoreline in the newfm last year
i believe that team is now up in the top 2 of NBN
Money to spend = Players = Results (most of the time)
Little money = average squads = average results
i don't see this changing in the near future
cheers
Adamstown 6 -0 Thornton
17 goals to nil for Atown in 4 days, I think they might win the comp
My first comments on the game are ...what on earth has happened to the pitch ? it was terrible and when I say terrible I dont mean as in just poor for this time of year. It truly was shocking and verging on dangerous for both sets of players.
Another good night for the buds and takes us one step closer to NBN football and I really cant see how we can throw it away from this position although never say never in football !! I thought all things considered it was a very easy night for Adamstown although fair credit to thornton who never gave up and work right to the final whistle.
Sunday against maitland will be interesting and in all honesty I cannot see maitland being able to handle Chappys team in their current form as they look likely to score with every attack at the moment and judging by last nights selection they have 2 or 3 players who will start and who did not last night and add more depth to that team that team.
Finally a big well done to the young 23s Adamstown team who collect the 3pts with a very hard game and the 0-2 scoreline was a tad harsh on thornton 23s who i thought played very well and merited something out the game.
This now sets up a cracker in the 23s comp as well up at Maitland on Sunday as I think the win takes Adamstown back to the top of the table with 2 games to go.
Last edited by Keep the long balls short; 01-08-2013 at 10:17 AM.