Quote Originally Posted by WOW2.0 View Post
I don?t get your point re: Weston?so now any talented kids they have will have to run away earlier, because those coming into 13s know there is a risk they?ll spend half the year in tier 2 (through absolutely no fault of their own)?so just fodder for poaching!
My point is that Weston team went from top 6 in Div A, to being put in Div 2 but not even making the semis in Div 2 despite being the highest ranked team after phase 1.If the main reason for that was because a couple of kids moved then how good a team were they and where do they deserve to be graded next year?If your team only succeeds because of a couple of players then every team is open to the same thing happening every year which makes grading by teams just as open to flaws as keeping clubs as one group.How the hell do you even begin to grade them fairly next year?