You would think Northern could keep the club championship up to date. Most recent version is March 19.
You would think Northern could keep the club championship up to date. Most recent version is March 19.
Originally Posted by Hunter403
In summary it looks like Cooks Hill, Weston and Mid Coast are dropping into Div 2.Everything else is pretty tight.
Latest as @ 8/4.
PPR DIV1 08042025.jpg
Going to be a long year for some teams when they make top 8 because enough of the other clubs teams did well.
One club having 2 age groups with zero points after 5 rounds and their other 3 age groups being undefeated is a pretty interesting stat.I think the other 2 age groups will be fine by seasons end though.
Div 2 if you have the time? Looking at the tables Southy and Charlestown look like making B but the last 2 could be a lottery
From what I saw Kahibah look good as well.4th spot is a close but 2 teams that stayed last year (Belswans and Rosebuds) are quite a bit back.Stags and Westy a chance.
Based on last year, Olympic had a team in this position...by the end of the 2nd phase they had gotten only a single point
Not sure anyone can just say those 2 teams will be fine by seasons end
I am not sure that is correct. This is what I have for 2024.
2024 PPR.jpg
I get your point but have seen one of those 2 teams a few times this year and how they havent won games let alone draw any surprises me.They play some good football and would still consider them one of the best 8 teams in their age group.It will be interesting to see where they are when the split happens.
Add New Lambton to those. They're gone. too many pretend coaches
You can take a look at the detailed break down I put into the 2024 PYL tab
You'll find what I said is accurate
Looking at Northerns table it appears that they have their ranking based on how difference and not club points accumulated thus far.
Changes a few teams around if go off points and not goal difference in their table
Looks like I will take an L on this one.
Yep, the top 8 is pretty settled now I think. Edgeworth are such a weird one - zero points in the 13s and 18s but right at the pointy end in 14s, 15s and 16s. My son's team played them in the 16s recently, and I reckon they are the most well drilled side, with a real plan and structure. Their coach was way over the top in his yelling at players, but he is certainly getting the best out of them.
I'm sure we all wanted to see after, 2 prior years of promotion/relegation, some changes in who goes up and down
Club championship model prevents that though keeps some underseving teams safe, etc...and ends up in greater cannabilisation of those nearly their teams (in some cases they are "there")
Nailed it.
Although this club championship model isnt perfect its better than what we had before and locally, the system is as good as its ever been.
Not sure how the draw goes if they decided to make individual teams go into different comps.
Back in the day Newcaste had 2 youth clubs in Sydney, bit like coasties have now. Not sure if this would be better or not now.
Last edited by Addios; 14-04-2025 at 11:18 AM.
It doesnt reward or entice that 1 team who have done well & have stuck by a "lower" club but then gets forced into a lower divison to stay with that club.
That's the flaw
I am sure there is a mathematical algorithm that could be applied to marry up a good draw with different teams in appropriate divisions and organise grounds...Victoria does it this way I believe, can't see why we couldn't.
Would help a club build something of themselves
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote