So, getting ahead of myself, I missed Peter McPherson and Nigel Boogaard's NSL appearances for the club. Updated appearance order

1 Brad Swancott
2 Andy Roberts
3 Chris Zoricich
4 Todd McManus
5 Travis Dodd
6 Mark Wilson
7 John Buonavoglia
8 Peter Tsekenis
9 Brad Wieczorek
10 Anthony Surjan
11 Esala Masi
12 Vasko Trpcevski
13 Glenn Sprod
14 Daniel McBreen
15 Peter Juchniewicz
16 Robert Catlin
17 James Kemp
18 Anthony Magnacca
19 Andrew Harper
20 Mitchell Johnson
21 Chad Mansley
22 Daniel Beltrame
23 Matthew Bingley
24 Joel Griffiths
25 Scott Baillie
26 Milan Blagojevic
27 Robbie Middleby
28 Joey Schirripa
29 Michael Prentice
30 John Majurovski
31 Tallan Martin
32 Alex Moreira
33 Adam Hughes
34 Scott Thomas
35 Adam Griffiths
36 Steve Eagleton
37 Ryan Griffiths
38 Jobe Wheelhouse
39 Tom Willis
40 Daniel Ciarrocchi
41 Thomas Libbesson
42 Josh Mitchell
43 Peter McPherson
44 Greg Owens
45 Damien Brown
46 Keegan Wolfenden
47 Craig Deans
48 John Perosh
49 Joel Theissen
50 Stuart Musialik
51 Mitchell Wallace
52 Jason Cowburn
53 Nigel Boogaard
54 Liam Reddy
55 Jade North
56 Ned Zelic
57 Andrew Durante
58 Richard Johnson
59 Matt Thompson
60 Ante Milicic
61 Nick Carle
62 Guy Bates
63 Labinot Haliti
64 Paul Kohler
65 Franco Parisi
66 Allan Picken
67 Mateo Corbo
68 Mark Bridge
69 Brett Studman
70 James Monie
71 Tarek Elrich
72 Vaughan Coveny
73 Ben Kennedy
74 Paul Okon
75 Shane Webb
76 Adam D'Apuzzo
77 Troy Hearfield
78 Tolgay Ozbey
79 Steven Old
80 Milton Rodriguez
81 Tim Brown
82 Ivan Necevski
83 Ante Covic
84 Scott Tunbridge
85 Noel Spencer
86 Jorge Drovandi
87 Denni Rocha Dos Santos
88 Jason Hoffman
89 Mario Jardel
90 Stephen Laybutt
91 James Holland
92 Song Jin-Hyung
93 Antun Kovacic
94 Beau Busch
95 Jarrad Ross
96 Kaz Patafta
97 Jason Naidovski
98 Ben Kantarovski
99 Jesper Hakansson
100 Edmundo Zura
101 Daniel Piorkowski
102 Marko Jesic
103 Mark Milligan
104 Shaun Ontong
105 Sean Rooney
106 James Virgili
107 Brodie Mooy
108 Jesse Pinto
109 Nikolai Topor-Stanley
110 Ljubo Milicevic
111 Sasho Petrovski
112 Donny De Groot
113 Fabio Vignaroli
114 Joel Wood
115 Angelo Costanzo
116 Chris Triantis
117 Ali Abbas
118 Michael Bridges
119 Neil Young
120 Mirjan Pavlovic
121 Scott Balderson
122 Kasey Wehrman
123 Ruben Zadkovich
124 Jeremy Brockie
125 Shuo Zhang
126 Marcello Fiorentini
127 Taylor Regan
128 Matthew Nash
129 Francis Jeffers
130 Jacob Pepper
131 Tomislav Misura
132 Samuel Gallaway
133 Mario Simic
134 Tiago Calvano
135 Sung-Hwan Byun
136 Jack Duncan
137 Chris Payne
138 Connor Chapman
139 Mark Birighitti
140 Scott Neville
141 Dominik Ritter
142 Craig Goodwin
143 Emile Heskey
144 Adam Taggart
145 Bernardo Ribeiro
146 Joshua Brillante
147 James Brown
148 Mitchell Oxborrow
149 Andrew Hoole
150 Zenon Caravella
151 Mitch Cooper
152 Kew Jaliens
153 Nathan Burns
154 Joey Gibbs
155 Nick Ward
156 David Carney
157 Jeronimo Neumann
158 Sam Gallagher
159 Adrian Madaschi
160 Jonny Steele
161 Brandon Lundy
162 Edson Montano
163 Marcos Flores
164 Allan Welsh
165 Nick Cowburn
166 Billy Celeski
167 Radovan Pavicevic
168 Daniel Mullen
169 Ki-Je Lee
170 Braedyn Crowley
171 Enver Alivodic
172 Max Burgess
173 Michael Kantarovski
174 Travis Cooper
175 Cameron Watson
176 Mateo Poljak
177 Milos Trifunovic
178 Leonardo Vitor Santiago
179 Lachlan Jackson
180 Ryan Kitto
181 Steven Ugarkovic
182 Morten Nordstrand
183 Andy Brennan
184 Wayne Brown
185 Andrew Nabbout
186 Devante Clut
187 Kristian Brymora
188 Aleksandr Kokko
189 Ivan Vujica
190 John Koutroumbis
191 Iain Fyfe
192 Ma Leilei
193 Harrison Sawyer
194 Tomislav Arcaba
195 Joel Allwright
196 Dimitri Petratos
197 Roy O'Donovan
198 Daniel Georgievski
199 Kosta Petratos
200 Ronald Vargas
201 Joe Champness
202 Mario Shabow
203 Glen Moss
204 Patricio Rodriguez
205 Angus Thurgate
206 Riley McGree
207 Matthew Ridenton
208 Jair Eduardo
209 Kaine Sheppard
210 Mitch Austin
211 Lewis Italiano
212 Jake Adelson
213 Kwabena Appiah-Kubi
214 Jack Simmons
215 Patrick Langlois
216 Abdiel Arroyo
217 Nick Fitzgerald
218 Matthew Millar
219 Wes Hoolahan
220 Bobby Burns
221 Maki Petratos
222 Bernie Ibini-Isei
223 Joe Ledley
224 Connor O'Toole
225 Lucas Mauragis
226 Noah James
227 Ramy Najjarine
228 Valentino Yuel
229 Tete Yengi
230 Blake Archbold
231 Luka Prso
232 Archie Goodwin
233 Apostolos Stamatelopoulos
234 Liridon Krasniqi
235 Syahrian Abimanyu
236 Jordan O'Doherty
237 Dane Ingham
238 Jordan Elsey
239 Matthew Jurman
240 Beka Mikeltadze
241 Olivier Boumal
242 Daniel Penha
243 Kosta Grozos
244 Savvas Siatravanis
245 Samuel Silvera
246 Riley Warland
247 Eli Babalj
248 Dylan Murnane
249 Mohamed Al-Taay