Quote Originally Posted by Hunter403 View Post
PYL tier 2. Cheers.

Div 2

Half season break
1. Charlestown ~ 112Pts (GD +140)
2. South Cardiff ~ 102Pts (GD +96)
3. Belswans ~ 93Pts (GD +81)
4. NIAS ~ 72Pts (GD+65) ? relegated despite
RELEGATED
5. Rosebuds ~ 72Pts (GD +57)
6. Kahibah ~ 70Pts (GD -32)
7. West Wallsend ~ 63Pts (GD +3)
8. Cessnock ~ 61Pts (GD -19)
9. Toronto ~ 33Pts (GD -156)
10. Thornton ~ 32Pts (GD -73)
11. Singleton ~ 20Pts (GD -162)
12. VACANT

Rosebuds missing games against Singleton in 16s & 14s (might explain the NIAS relegation). If the games didn't go ahead, they obviously won't be now.

Of those relegated out of top 4 positions
(4 clubs staying in tier 2)
U13: NIAS 1st
U14: Kahibah 1st
U15: Kahibah 1st
U16: NIAS 4th
U18: West Wallsend 4th

Of the safe teams:
The luckiest team sits in 8th position with 3 wins, 2 draws
(negative GD, and a win ratio of just 30%)

Team with the best Goals For: shared
NIAS U13s & Charlestown U16s
(Both on 50, NIAS with the better goal difference, conceding just 7)

Team with the Lowest GA: Charlestown U15s (4)

Highest win ratio:
(Team) South Cardiff U16s ~ 90%
(Club) Charlestown ~ 72.9%


Top 4 each age group: (if finals were held today/relegation was by team and not club)
13s ~ NIAS, Rosebuds, South Cardiff, Charlestown

14s ~ Kahibah, Charlestown, Rosebuds, Belswans

15s ~ Kahibah, Charlestown, Belswans, South Cardiff

16s ~ South Cardiff, Belswans, Charlestown, NIAS

18s ~ Charlestown, South Cardiff, Belswans, West Wallsend

Which would be fairer, TBH
With 3 teams in first place being relegated

NIAS 13s have the greatest GD in tier II, of any age group (+43)?how does tier III now benefit those kids? To play against teams with a -42 or -58 GD for the rest of the year

How does Kahibah retain and grow for next year? If pro/rel was by team they could build on the successes of those 1st places. Now, their most talented kids will likely look elsewhere?because, despite their team and individual "excellence", they are pushed down by averages.

It would have been right to have let those kids play out the remainder of the year, and earn a trophy they deserve before a reshuffle based on club average