I think use are both correct. What I don't like us when you get a cal against your team and I approach the ref to ask a simple question, you get no answer. As captain isn't that my right to do so?Originally Posted by Wilso8948
That goose on Saturday was bad for both teams. Me and Bj were both asking questions and the one reply we always got was "I'm not sure". If your not sure, why are you making calls for!
Exactly. And when I asked after the game why he blew for a pen and pointed to the spot he said "no I didn't" and we all saw him do it. Hence why we celebrated lol. He said that he pointed in the air and blew time off. Then asked why was it a free kick and he said "I don't know exactly but I think it was because dungog had the ball" even though the ball went out for a corner... Anyways hope we never get him anymore he was a muppet
Far from state of the art, but we'll have lights.
He was the best ref we have had this year and I don't think any of his decisions influenced the match.
Wilso you didn't even know which guy made the tackle, and I know for a fact he did not point to the spot. He blew the whistle and did nothing! Me and everyone didn't know why he blew at first. The Lino (who referred v Simba ressies- not a ring in) had the best view at it called it correctly. It was a text book covering tackle! Didn't even look like your guys were going to even appeal, until you were pretty much yelling for the foul on your way down to the ground.
For everyone's information, I believe there is 17 rules now and I believe the only thing that you would find mentioning a tackle from behind being serious foul play is a lunge. Doesn't matter weather it is from front, side or behind a lunge( one or two footed) is serious foul play and game should be brought to a stop with no advantages played.
The weekends tackle was not a lunge or had any dangerous intent. A very clean and simple defensive tackle
Must say the Kurri referees done a great job on Saturday last week.
Also the little bloke for Kurri " weeman " when he came on he made a big difference , goes great for his size .
I know exactly who made the tackle. I didn't shake anyone's hand I tapped AJ on the head cause he was giving me shit for going down. Sorry but when your 1-0 about to shoot then u get your legs taken out from underneath u I'd be pretty concerned if you weren't appealing. And u know for a fact he didn't blow a pen? Explain to me why he pointed to the spot with a horizontal arm. I know the tackle had no serious intent I want to hope no one makes a tackle with serious intent but contact in the box is contact in the box and should be dealt with accordingly. Also you are not allowed to "lunge" from behind whether you get ball or not. Anyways back to my original complaint which wasn't actually the pen it was the fact that then if the tackle was deemed as "fair" then why does the ball then go out and get called a corner?
And if that's the best ref you guys have had before then I'd be extremely extremely concerned
Just gave the situation to an A-league and state league ref, he said it doesn't sound like a foul. He pretty much said exactly what I just said about the rules. I will give you a link for the rules book and I will wait to see if you can find anything to do with the sort tackle you got on the weekend! like the linesman said, he got the ball and the contact was just from the follow through and that he believed you may have made it look worse than it was! which is a rule, hence him giving the free to Dungog.
I believe I wrote that you can not lunge from any angle and that any lunge should bring an immediate stop to play, with a caution to follow!
Yes true, the best referee we have had this year!
If you want to get right in to the rules, than your filthy mouthed coach would not have remained on the sideline, nor probably at least two players who deemed it necessary to constantly to produce the same language for most of the game at the top of their lungs.
You can't tell me that we are the only team swearing on the weekend? So why then wasn't I cautioned in the eyes of the ref for diving? Why could he not explain to me after the game that it was a free kick after that? And not say that "dungog had the ball so they got the kick" wtf does that mean? Does that mean its a drop ball?? Even though the ball went out for a corner? You can't tell me that guy on the line was an official and had a better look then the man in the middle. If he's an official then should be dressed accordingly. Honestly would have rathered the chick running the other line to come out and ref. Had her before and never have an issue. Everytime we've had old mate it's a reoccurring thing that he gives idiotic responses and fumbles his words and cannot explain a single decision. Everyone has an opinion to certain decisions I fully agree but you also need to explain as to why you've made those decisions. Just like you said "he blew the whistle and no one even knew what for"
Happens most games. The ref i had on the weekend was spot on - getting the ball first means nothing if you follow through causing danger to the other player. Big interpretation though and most refs will let it go to a point.
next topic champs, this is done.
Yer I agree. And also agree that it's refs opinion and I accept this guys decision I just don't accept the following events and
his interpretation of what went down.
Anyways we need to massively improve this weekend and a lot of teams will struggle to take points home after a trip up the Gog.
can ignore manu supporters
No mate, don't have a probably with some swearing from a bad shot, miss hit pass etc but yelling across the field at your coach for most of the game and the coach yelling back! Then to add to it, many complaints from the crowd at ht about your keeper doing the same all half yelling out to the players with the language.
She normally is our ref, and would love if everyone seen the challenge! He didn't have his shirt on because he was there to watch his cousin and got pressured in to doing a line.
Anyway you guys were clearly relying on one decision to get some sort of result out this one, so I think our boys deserved the win showing a lot more heart out there.
And yes hawk that is the interpretation of the rules and he knows he was never ever in Danger from a tackle like that! Not the slightest bit of danger involved
I'm just going to leave this one. You're clearly not understanding anything I have said and what my issues are. Good luck to everyone this weekend
Mate I think you need to open up your other eye. Your are clearly one eyed when it comes to dungog! Go back and read wilso's post and realize what he is trying to say. As captain I wasn't happy with the swearing but it was coming from both sides. I think everyone knew what was at stake and were showing a lot of emotion out there. Yes I think dungog deserved the win but I will say I agree with wilso and hawk that the rule is you can't make contact into the back of a player in the box, especially when he is in a scoring position
Bj don't be so all high and mighty on this circumstance. Yes dungog deserved the win. Our boys weren't up for it and didn't adjust as they should have.
But I distinctly remember in last years grandfinal you calling me a 'f****ing cheat' repeatedly and telling me you 'wouldn't shake my hand cause I was nothing more than a dirty f***ing cheat!' At the end of the game because you didn't get what you wanted. Not to mention your keeper telling your players just to start 'taking out their f****ing players and start f***ing hurting them c***' once you guys were out of the game. All of which can be heard on the video of the game. Just because this time the decisions didn't hurt you don't try and take the high ground on questioning the ref and swearing.
Last edited by rolo; 14-05-2013 at 11:15 AM.
So when do Dungog v Stockton play again ? I am so going hahaha.....
This week
Draw
Stockton
Draw
Toronto
Going for some upsets
Kurri
Stocko
Bero
Toronto
Well rolo I think you wouldn't be happy if we played on while one of your players was down and then scoring during that passage, which we had practically stopped playing due to our injuried player in quite some pain. Any who, I'm happy to end it here,
-just don't make us sound like we rely on referees to win up at the gog
-still fail to see what makes you think it was foul, never would that have been a foul in my 18 years of playing!
Any who, another tough game for us to travel to bero. Be good keep on top with Simba v stocko next weekend
Despite our chats on here youaskedforit, stocko v Dungog is always a very entertaining and physical game, with not to many bad tackles. Normally played a lot quickie than our individual usual games
And fully agree here. We always have our differences but always good mates afterwards. I am certainly not suggesting dungog rely on refs to win games. Stocko played shit. Dungog played good. Won the game. End of story. Just have a massive issue with that ref cause in my opinion he's a douchebag. Not because of that decision. That part is up to him. It's just a constant issue whenever I have played a game with that ref where he has no clue wtf he is doing and gets confused all the time.
But all in all that's why we love football. Mates like myself and BJ can always have differing opinions and fight about it till the cows come home (all the way to dungog) but there is always the next game to look forward to
Posting Permissions
