The endless (and probably pointless) GK debate thread.

[joel31]

sell him to further his career but we better get a good replacement

[goaliepersempre]

If I remember right the Gypos done the same when they sold Amini to Dortmund

Got the money and Amini done a bit of pre season work at Dortmund before returning to play for the Gypos on loan in the HAL for another year before making the move to germany permanently

and that gypo wanker is doing so well hahahahaha.....

[MFKS]

and that gypo wanker is doing so well hahahahaha.....

The bloke is playing at one of the top 10 sides in Europe

To expect him to walk into the side is a bit harsh within 2 years of leaving the HAL


The bloke has a few years there and fails so what he can then get a gig elsewhere and will be a much better player for his experience

[Grimario]

Reckon Biraz move to Leverkusen is off after Hyypia was sacked?

[Thomas477]

Reckon Biraz move to Leverkusen is off after Hyypia was sacked?

**** I hope so.

[Jeterpool]

sell him to further his career but we better get a good replacement

I guess we need to question are there any quality keepers sitting on the sideline at another club AND coming off contract who are an improvement on BK?

I'm struggling to think of one myself.

[joel31]

I guess we need to question are there any quality keepers sitting on the sideline at another club AND coming off contract who are an improvement on BK?

I'm struggling to think of one myself.

We have free foreign spots

[WolfMan]

We have as a country produced many fine Goalkeepers over the years. Foreign spot on one would be a waste

[Jetmaster]

We have as a country produced many fine Goalkeepers over the years. Foreign spot on one would be a waste

This - not many O/S keepers have come here, let alone be successful. Best to get one of the experienced Aussie keepers overseas or recycle a good one here.

[MFKS]

Congrats to this bloke making the WC Training Squad

Love your work



Sure the BK Lovers will be eating dick as we speak

Newys No 1

[la bazzle]

Legend. Nice one birraz

[Grimario]

Apart from a few select people, I think most will agree that he is a far superior keeper to BK. But the way he went to shit once he was in the media as moving to Germany, being a WC bolter and then the "I don't give a shit that I ****ed up majorly and lost us the game against the club's biggest rival" drama... made perfect sense to drop him and get him focused a bit.

If he isn't #1 next season it will be because he has made the WC 30 man squad and an overseas club has taken a gamble on him, not because he isn't better than BK.

[Blackmac79]

Talented twat

[joel31]

Congrats to him. It will be a good experience training with the best

[GazFish35]

I'm not sure any of the "BK lovers" (of which I'm a vocal member) would argue that birraz isn't a better keeper.

Most of the arguments for bk arent that he's better, but just that gets the treatment he deserves, not all the abuse he doesn't deserve.... And that birraz is held to account just as much.

Congrats birraz. Hope he gets to go.

[pessimist]

we are stuffed without birraz

[plague]

we are stuffed without birraz

We won a grand final without him.

[Jeterpool]

We won a grand final without him.

Yeah but we had a better keeper than birraz between the sticks that day

[stopper2]

I'm not sure any of the "BK lovers" (of which I'm a vocal member) would argue that birraz isn't a better keeper.

Most of the arguments for bk arent that he's better, but just that gets the treatment he deserves, not all the abuse he doesn't deserve.... And that birraz is held to account just as much.

Congrats birraz. Hope he gets to go.

Well said Fish.

[militiamon]

Yeah but we had a better keeper than birraz between the sticks that day

Jimmy Holland?